Something went wrong. Try again later
    Follow

    Doom

    Game » consists of 30 releases. Released Dec 10, 1993

    In one of the most revolutionary first-person shooters of the 1990s, players control the last remaining space marine in the demon-infested stations on Mars' moons.

    sbc515's Doom (Saturn) review

    Avatar image for sbc515

    Rip and tear this inferior port apart!

    Doom is a first-persons shooter game developed and published by id Software. Originally released for MS-DOS back in November 1993. This game, along with Wolfenstein 3D, is known to revolutionize the first-person shooter genre, and since its release, it's been ported to loads of consoles from the 32X to the eighth generation consoles. This article will cover the Sega Saturn version developed by Liverpool-based studio Rage Software and published by GT Interactive.

    Programmer Jim Bagley, upon receiving the resources from id Software, was able to create a hardware-accelerated renderer for the platform in a relatively short amount of time. However, upon review by John Carmack, this rendering engine was found unacceptable due to the hardware's quad-based affine texture scaling. Carmack demanded that the hardware graphics capabilities be avoided, forcing Bagley to undertake writing a software renderer which utilized both SH2 processor units in the system, under coordination of the central 68000 chip, to draw the screen in a manner similar to the PC game engine. According to Sega Retro, earlier builds were compatible with the 3D Control Pad, but the feature was removed from the final game. John Carmack would later regret the decision to disallow the 3D hardware on 8 October, 2014, stating that “I hated affine texture swim and integral quad verts, but in hindsight, I probably should have let experiment.”

    North American/European cover art is pretty decent, but loads of false advertising plagues the back of the boxes for those boxes. The biggest example is that the North American box states it has 60 levels, while the European box states it has 55 levels, neither of which are true as it has 59 levels in it. The screenshots for both boxes are also actually taken from the PC version of Final Doom and not from in-game. The North American box even states it supports multiplayer via linkup, which is not present in the version, and only present in the European version of the port.

    The most infamous thing about this port, is the dreadful framerate, with the game staying around 12 FPS for most of the game, but it gets worse during the later levels, where the framerate dips to 10 FPS with slideshow quality levels of smooth. A rumour circulated that the Japanese version was a little more optimised than the North American and European versions, however, this claim was debunked by DigitalFoundry commentator John Linnerman, who found no difference in the framerate. Due to the awful framerate, Doomguy is very poor to control in this version, where he has less reaction time than the other versions and he moves like a drunk lad. Enemies are also noticeably weaker than the other ports, as they attack slower, either due to the terrible framerate. Worse, sound effects are a lot more slower and lower pitched in this version, due to the game using a lower sample rate, which doesn’t good for the majority of the game.

    Just like the PlayStation version, it allows you to play either Final Doom and Doom II, which adds more content that is worth playing (although for some odd reason, for levels 10-20 in Doom 2, it uses a cityscape sky texture, even for levels in Hell, which can come off as ridiculous and stupid). But what you may have noticed is that a lot of features are completely removed from the PS1 version, with the most notable being coloured lighting, leading to areas more washed-out than the PS1 version, and the multiplayer in the North American version, as mentioned above. Also, the soundtrack compared to the PS1 version is limited (which this port is based on), as certain tracks are repeated more often in some levels, though, there are unused tracks on the disc in the Redbook audio. But, even if it's limited, it's still awesome, due to the fact that it uses the PlayStation version of the soundtrack.

    This version is doomed.

    Other reviews for Doom (Saturn)

      Get The Playstation Version Instead 0

      The Playstation version of Doom was a great way to set off the Playstation back in 1995, because at the time, Doom was an absolutely outstanding game in almost every way. Midway had improved the visuals by including lighting effects and upgraded textures, recreated the soundtrack, added new sound effects and moulded the game to also include link-up two player co-op and death match modes. What made the Playstation version of Doom standout from all the others as well was that it was complet...

      0 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.