The game that deserves a 10/10 most...

cod4, dude, i have never played online before i got a ps3 and bought this game. now i have almost 11 days worth online and im sure it will be atleast 15-20 before im done with it. i know a lot of people may argue this, but i have never played games this much before. 

"Soul Calibur IV, seriously I'm loving this game right now.  And I can't really think of any others at the moment.
"

I think a game shouldn't have to be "perfect" to get the highest score. Everyone is going to have a different opinion on what makes a game perfect so I think that games that are simply amazingly well designed and fun should be awarded with a 10/10. Anyway I think Pokemon Red/Blue should be awarded a 10 because of how fun and addictive the gameplay was and how impressive it was for it's time.

Grim Fandango

Chrono Trigger

In my mind, the perfect game hasn't been created yet so there isn't one.

totally agree with re4. mgs3 also. and halo 3.

Final Fantasy X.

Bioshock