The other thread on the front page "Crappy albums by good bands" got me thinking that a lot of bands out there, no matter how good, have at least one clunker in their discography. So, the question arose: Which one of your favorite bands has never released a poor album in your eyes? Try to keep the bands at a minimum of 4 or 5 albums because saying that one band released 2 good albums isn't really saying much.
The first band that comes to mind for me is Alkaline Trio, while some "purist" fans may hate me for it, I've enjoyed everything that band has produced.
Bands who never had a clunker
Poets of the Fall and Midnight Brown come to mind immediately. It's a hard question. I like Metallica a bunch, but I don't really enjoy their early stuff. And I tend to cherry pick songs from artists rather than listen to an entire album.
For me personally, the Red Hot Chili Peppers haven't released a "bad" album yet. One Hot Minute was probably the weakest so far, but not what I would call "bad." Another artist that comes to mind would be Rie Fu.
Porcupine Tree has changed it's style several times but I feel all of their albums have been excellent.
@Milkman said:
" The first band that comes to mind for me is Alkaline Trio, while some "purist" fans may hate me for it, I've enjoyed everything that band has produced. "Thanks, mate. You've just picked my afternoon music selection for me. Man, those guys have some great pop rock tunes.
@spazmaster666 said:
" One Hot Minute was probably the weakest so far, but not what I would call "bad." "See, I loved One Hot Minute and have a good friend who thinks I'm batpoop loopy because I hold this opinion. The current-day Peppers output (say, the last couple of albums) sound like they're treading water to me, though.
Well, musically speaking, the Chili Peppers have definitely continued to get better over the years (John in particular, I mean compare him post Californication era vs. him during BSSM era and there's no contest). And personally as much as I loved Blood Sex Sugar Magik, you really can't blame them for growing up and playing some more serious tunes. Also, Stadium Arcadium could have been their best album, if they had trimmed some of the fat.See, I loved One Hot Minute and have a good friend who thinks I'm batpoop loopy because I hold this opinion. The current-day Peppers output (say, the last couple of albums) sound like they're treading water to me, though. "
I just want to preface this by stating that, although GB has a fairly open minded community, I still feel as though this thread is headed toward a flamewar. That being said, one of the bands who have produced many albums, all of which I have enjoyed for their own merits, in the recent past is: Incubus. I think they've provided a relatively high quality and varied product with each album they've produced. Just throwing in my two cents...though undoubtedly there are many who think me a fool for my opinion.
pantera? well...
if you only include their CD's from 1990 and up. cowboys was awesome, vulgar is GENIUS, FBD was super heavy but still good, i didn't like Southern Trendklil but apparently a lot of people did, and reinventing the steel was decent.
slayer because all of their music sounds the same, and if you like one CD you'll like all of them.
iron maiden never had a TERRIBLE CD for the same reason slayer didn't. although brave new world was kind of underwhelming to a lot of people.
and mastodon because mastodon is awesome.
mgmt because they've only released two CD's both of which are AAMAAAAAZING
Just a few from me:
Amon Tobin - Everything this dude does is awesome. Even Foley Room, while not his best work, was still a really interesting experiment and yielded some great tracks. I first heard him in 1998 and for years I would say he should do the score to a Bond film. Things went one better for me years later when he did the soundtrack to Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory. I mean, what gets better than Amon Tobin doing a filmic score for a video game?
Ben Folds - I honestly can't think of anything that was crap. Even the bogus Way To Normal album he made was great, and that was just him cocking around.
Cop Shoot Cop - They did some stuff that wasn't as good as other stuff, but I bought every album and loved every one of 'em. The frowned-upon (by CSC purists) 1994 album Release is one of my favourites by them and was a great way for them to go out.
QOTSA - Even though I think Era Vulgaris is their weakest album, there's still enough meat there to keep it out of clunker territory.
First band that comes to mind is probably Poets of the Fall, although Revolution Roulette wasn't really up to their standards, it was still better than the shit most bands shovel out.
Probably the Roots as well.
And in my mind, Aesop Rock, but that's sort of a love-it-or-hate-it pick. Also, he's not in a band. Oh well.
" iron maiden never had a TERRIBLE CD... "Yeah, going through all the music on my machine I saw Iron Maiden there, but couldn't in good conscience say they never had a bad album because I haven't bought any of the later stuff. In fact, the last one I bought was SSoaSS.
" The Roots, 10 albums strong now, not a single bad record. "I'd agree just because Rising Down isn't so much a clunker as it is a disappointment (decent, however).
LCD Soundsystem. I know I'm obsessed with them and whatnot but those three albums (or I guess 5 if you count each CD of the debut as a separate album, and also 45:33 but that and the remix CD seems more like an awesome side-project rather than an actual album) are phenomenal. Nary a bad song in any album.
" @buzz_clik said:To me It seems like crazy-talk to insinuate, that the album that gave a band their mainstream break-through, should somehow be considered the one album that come closest at being defined as "bad"Well, musically speaking, the Chili Peppers have definitely continued to get better over the years (John in particular, I mean compare him post Californication era vs. him during BSSM era and there's no contest). And personally as much as I loved Blood Sex Sugar Magik, you really can't blame them for growing up and playing some more serious tunes. Also, Stadium Arcadium could have been their best album, if they had trimmed some of the fat. "See, I loved One Hot Minute and have a good friend who thinks I'm batpoop loopy because I hold this opinion. The current-day Peppers output (say, the last couple of albums) sound like they're treading water to me, though. "
The closest any of my favorite bands come to having a perfect track record so to speak is Pearl Jam, but they have one album I don't love. There ARE a handful of really good songs on that album though, so I don't hate it. So yeah, I guess in my opinion Pearl Jam.
(btw, the album in question is Binaural)
Trololololololololololololololololololololol" Nickelback, Soulja Boy, Justin Beiber, Dragonforce, Ke$ha "
Of course people will disagree, but I utterly love everything SOAD and Rise Against have put out.
If we only count studio albums, Led Zeppelin and The Doors (Morrison albums). The Beatles, too but that's a given in my book. I can't think of any others because the longer a band exists the great their chance of a misfire.
Im going to have to go with Coheed and Cambria. I personally enjoyed everything they have released so far.
AC/DC, The Beatles, Beastie Boys, Billy Talent, Big Wreck/Thornley are the only ones that come to mind for me.
I can think of a lot of others who were close, but had one stinker in their library.
(lotta Bs in there)
Simple. ALICE IN CHAINS, before Layne died, even their not so popular songs are hits, Jerry Cantrell is an excellent composer and writer definately in my top 5 of greatest writers of all time in popular music, and he doesn't get as much credit as he deserves. & Layne was a badass man, could make any song his own, goddamit the bastard why couldn't he have lived!
I'd probably include Deftones in the list as well they always put 100% in their songs.
" I think that Muse's albums just get better and better! "I would have agreed with you before their latest offering, not that great. or should I say not as good.
The black seeds, A great NZ band,
Eskimo Joe, An Aussie Band.
There are many bands that I would love to say, but there is always one that just doesn't tack up.
Rise Against, I'd say. They have five albums that I know of - four of which are major releases, and one of which is just a small release. The weakest in my eyes is likely either The Unraveling or Revolutions Per Minute, though I'd gladly listen to either album due to the fact that they're great. They're the worst by Rise Against, but that does not make them bad in my eyes.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment