What is your favorite Pop-Tarts flavor?

@MysteriousBob said:

You Americans are crazy, we only have Strawberry and Chocolate.

We're crazy? Because we have several flavors of a fruit tart? Come off your high horse buddy, it's just food

Strawberry frosted are classic for me. Ugh, now I really want one. You just single-handedly ruined my night.

(E) Chocolate Fudge. I don't eat them cuz I count calories nowadays, and you have sent me spiralling into relapse with your post!

blueberry

The mint and chocolate is the best.

Where the fuck is Wild Berry, I WILL NOT CHOOSE OTHER, I refuse to respond to this poll! This is a disgrace! Who are you to spit upon the name of Wild berry Pop tarts by not placing it in the poll. You fiend, you heathen, you... I chose S'Mores, those things are delicious.

i prefer the strawberry, cherry, smores, and brown sugar flavors.

the brown sugar cinnamon ones are the best.

Milk Chocolate Graham, and they're back! Try them if you get a chance.

Strawberry. Classic.

Wild berry is the only answer. It doesn't really matter how they taste, but they look like you're in a roller rink from the 90's

As someone who loved Pop-Tarts until last Fall semester when I had several nights eating nothing but Pop-Tarts for dinner: fuck Pop-Tarts.

My favorite poptart flavor are these things called Toaster Stroodles.

My second favorite is strawberry and chocolate.

Pop Tarts taste like cardboard

Now Pillsbury Toaster Strudels, with icing you can put on yourself? Thats a real means toaster pastry.

Frosted Strawberry all the way.

Peanut butter and jelly. yes they existed.

Beyond the question of how the heck this thread got bumped after all this time, this remains the only answer.

Brown sugar and cinnamon is the best as far as I'm concerned.

I only had a few flavours, since I have to import them, if I want Pop Tarts - the Cinnamon ones were my favorites. They smell so good when toasted.

We don't have these in Australia except in shops that import foreign confectionery and drinks (usually from the US and UK). I bought some chocolate fudge ones on a whim a while back. They were horrid. Have never gone back to try another flavour.

THIS!

Brown Sugar Cinnamon. No wait, fudge. No wait... Smores. wait wait wait... Wild Berry.

Pop Tarts are good as shit.

Also warm or not at all. Fuck a room temperature Pop Tart.

I like the good 'ol Frosted Strawberry. The S'mores flavors are really good too. I also like the Cookies and Creme and Wildberry flavors. That being said, I don't eat poptarts that much. Maybe a few times a year.

And for people asking about the flavors, they have a list on their website. Not sure what flavors they have overseas, but you can find all of these in the US pretty much anywhere.
http://www.poptarts.com/flavors

Strawberry - Not Frosted.

Peanut butter.

Weird, I'm not getting any of the poll options. I guess out of all the choices based on what everyone is posting, I'd say S'mores.

I've only ever seen 2 kinds, chocolate and strawberry and the chocolate ones are FUCKING DISGUSTING.

Frosted strawberry is the one and only.

Brown sugar cinnamon is bland and overrated. Yeah, I said it.

We had them but they got taken off shelves because, well, they're unhealthy as fuck. As for flavours, chocolate ones were actually bad, don't go by those. The fruit ones are the only way to go.

Such a fool. Wild Berry is the only choice. I mean, it's so loved that they barely sell them anymore!

Edit: HOLY NECRO BATMAN!!

Wild Berry and Smores are my two favourites.

Edit: This is the right kind of necro.

Edit 2: Now that I have taken part in this thread, I guess I am a necrophiliac.

I feel like I've seen this thread before....

I also feel like I've tossed my opinion into it before, but a quick scan says nope.

Brown sugar cinnamon.

I'll only eat the fruit ones, and of those my favorite is blueberry. At least with my blueberry pop tart I can pretend I'm not just eating candy. That's a lot harder to do with s'mores.

I had some blueberry ones and some brown sugar ones this weekend.

They were each, quite nice.

Frosted Blueberry!

I have never tried a Pop Tart before. They definitly sold them when I was a kid but they were not the sort of thing my parents would buy. And I don't think I've ever seen them as an adult outside those shops that import weird American junk food, like Lucky Charms which they sell from between two & three times the price of a similarly sized box of normal cereal like Corn Flakes or Golden Grahams.

Yeah.... not sure how anyone actually even found this thread. lol

WILD BERRY!!!

Frosted Raspberry

@humanity said:

Pop Tarts taste like cardboard

Now Pillsbury Toaster Strudels, with icing you can put on yourself? Thats a real means toaster pastry.

Hah, yeah. Pop Tarts are definitely a cheap snack. But that's part of the appeal!

Toaster Strudels are the real deal though. I used to take all the frosting and snack on that alone; putting it on always felt too messy. I'd rather toast it up real good and scoff em down than fiddle with glazing them. Though occasionally I'd go crazy with it and put like 3 packs of icing on one. Serious strudel customization options.

Strawberry was the go-to there as well, but apple and strawberry with cream cheese were legit as fuck.

Also holy shit how did I never try this:

Fuckin ice cream on a toaster strudel (also apple pie filling).

I don't think I've had Pop Tarts ever. I should probably try them some time. That Pilsbury Strudel posted above looks awesome though.

This man and his truth necroed from the ground.

Brown sugar or s'mores.

S'mores are the only Pop-Tarts I will even remotely get down with.

I haven't had Pop-Tarts in a dog's age. My go to used to be strawberry. Frosted of course, I'm not some sort of nut case.

I'm not sure they had smores back when I last par-took. At the very least I never tried it if they did.

When I was actually eating the things, I'd prefer to just pour a giant glob of icing on top rather than making those intricate lines.

Toaster Strudel is technically ever-so-slightly more "high class" amongst low-class things, but man I would probably take any flavor pop-tart over them as they're both technically more a dessert food than a breakfast and poptarts just seem more desserty. Especially when you get into the chocolate/smores flavors.

Smores is pretty fucking amazing, but cherry is a close second for me.

Frosted Cherry is the pinnacle of Pop-Tarts flavours.

Pop-Tarts are gross. Please don't hit me. *winces*