Who Else thinks Brett Favre Should Shut up and Retire

i used to absolutely love the guy and im a panthers fan so its not like i had some alliegance to him before but he is not even near what he used to be, he is losing tons of fans daily, and is putting the packers through tons of stress that doesnt help them or himself

I think it's fine.  Look, the guy loves the game and he didn't fully realize what it would be like to retire.  Now he's coming back while he still can.  Whatever.

I have lost a lot of respect for Brett Favre the past couple of years.  He's become a selfish attention whore.

Didn't he retire though?

Or was that a hoax and he came back..

"Didn't he retire though?

Or was that a hoax and he came back.."

Who?

"Who?"

Never heard of him...

Money and Fame do that to people. Oh Brett you selfish attention whore ( Thnx to CitizenKane for a good way of putting it)

I don't think you guys are paying Favre the respect he deserves.

I don't want to sound too harsh, but "fuck Brett Favre!"

He was a great quarterback and I respect what he did for the game. This is coming from a Bears fan. But he just needs to retire, I'm tired of hearing about it everyday on ESPN.

He should come back only if the Packers want him back.  Too many great players end their careers with the wrong team... think Joe Montana as a Chief, Emmitt Smith as a Cardinal, and Jerry Rice as a Seahawk or Raider... whatever team he was on last.

Brett Favre as anything other than a Packer is just wrong.

I tihnk he deserves every right to come back. He's a good fucking football player stuck with an organization thats is doing everything to have him go away. Sucks to be him right now

you cant blame the man for loving football he still wants to play I have all the respect in the world for the man one of the best to play but yeah he needs to let it go and retire

The Packers are just angry because he couldn't throw at all in his last game.

I say he should just retire...... but in the end it is his choice, not mine.

One of the most over rated athletes of our time.

"One of the most over rated athletes of our time.
"

But then what would ESPN talk about 23 hours a day?

Think of the media please.

i do, its starting to hurt his image severely. he is losing a lot of respect. sure a lot of you will defend him , but look around, many are agreeing with me so its obvious its definitely hurting his image. people think he's going nuts. everyone knows its tough to retire from a sport you love and are great at, but thousands have done it before him so it cant be that difficult. 

He has lost a lot of my respect. I think if he avoided all this drama, I would have no problem with him coming back for another year.

He is overrated.

"i do, its starting to hurt his image severely. he is losing a lot of respect. sure a lot of you will defend him , but look around, many are agreeing with me so its obvious its definitely hurting his image. people think he's going nuts. everyone knows its tough to retire from a sport you love and are great at, but thousands have done it before him so it cant be that difficult. "

Apparently he's been doing this same shit for a while now, expect now he actually did retire this time. I say fk him.

I kinda want to see him in Vikings purple just for the hell of it... hey if the Packers don't think Farve is good enough to beat out Aaron Rodgers for the starting QB... then it shouldn't be a problem even if it's to a division rival

"I kinda want to see him in Vikings purple just for the hell of it... hey if the Packers don't think Farve is good enough to beat out Aaron Rodgers for the starting QB... then it shouldn't be a problem even if it's to a division rival
"

Make his mind up. Thats all I gotta say about him. Retire or Not.

Brett will never die!

"suneku said:

"I kinda want to see him in Vikings purple just for the hell of it... hey if the Packers don't think Farve is good enough to beat out Aaron Rodgers for the starting QB... then it shouldn't be a problem even if it's to a division rival
"

Trade him into the Vikings in Madden 08
"

"suneku said:

"I kinda want to see him in Vikings purple just for the hell of it... hey if the Packers don't think Farve is good enough to beat out Aaron Rodgers for the starting QB... then it shouldn't be a problem even if it's to a division rival
"

Trade him into the Vikings in Madden 08
"

I don;t necessarily want him to retire, but man do i want the "Brett Farve" saga to end. Everyday I have to hear more and more crap about a story i honestly don't care for. I watch Pardon The Interruption pretty much every day and all they do is lead with Farve.  I hope where ever Brett Farve ends up playing he Blows ass, so this story becomes that much more pointless.

I think that if he wants to play the game, and he's still good, then let the man play. Giving up something you've been doing for 17 years is hard. However, I do think that if he's not up to it skill-wise, then he should retire, or whatnot. I love Brett Favre. He's put a lot into the game, and is a shining example that age doesn't matter when you're meant to play the game, but you gotta stop sometime.

How many times has he retired so far? Didn't he retire last year too?