2019 Game of the Year
Would like to play:
Luigi's Mansion 3
Best Looking Game: A Plague Tale Innocence
One might not expect a game about plague infested rats set in the middle ages to stand out for it's art and graphics, but Plague Tale is an all around gorgeous game. Between the sights, the lighting, and just the overall graphical quality on PC, I was constantly stopping to look around and marvel at the view.
Best Service: Xbox Game Pass
I keep thinking Game Pass is too good to be true and expect them to raise prices or remove a bunch of games from the service, but it just keeps getting better. Adding a separate PC version of the service and offering it in one package with the Xbox version was a brilliant move. I might not have even played a couple of the games on my top 10 this year were it not for Game Pass, and all Microsoft published games being available on the service from day one continues to be an incredible deal.
Most Disappointing: Bethesda Shooters
The idea of id and Avalanche getting together to make a more over the top Rage sequel had me intrigued by Rage 2. While the combat was fun and reminiscent of DOOM, the open world they created was so lifeless and repetitive that I couldn't make it halfway through before moving on. That taste of the great DOOM style combat made it all the more disappointing when Eternal got delayed into 2020. Combined with the Wolfenstein Youngblood reviews being so bad that I skipped it altogether, 2019 was a pretty rough year for Bethesda shooters.
Indies That Didn't Quite Hit: Ape Out, Katana Zero, My Friend Pedro
Several indie games this year should have been right up my alley, and I did enjoy a few hours of each of these. I would consider all of them well made games, they just didn't have that little extra something to push me to the finish line.