So let me explain the numbering here. Shantae and Let It Die both came out at the end of the year. I feel passionate about both of them, but didn't want to drop any other games. So they go on the end. On to the list!
Honorable Mentions: Nekopara Vol. 2, Senran Kagura: Estival Versus, Fire Emblem Fates, Superhot, Amplitude, Fairy Fencer F: Advent Dark Force, Titanfall 2, 100 Ft Robot Golf
Less Honorable Mention - Zero Time Dilemma (I was satisfied yet pretty disappointed with this ending)
Old Game of the Year: Rocksmith Remastered (I play it basically every dang day)
Best Anime Sequel/Conclusion To A Game Series: Danganronpa 3