My Thoughts on RB3 so far and response to JJWeatherman's RB3 blog
By melcene 11 Comments
JJ Weatherman's blog post on RB3 can be found here. It was a well-written informative blog post.
Keyboard/ Pro-Keys
I was right there with you on Pro Keys vs. Regular Keys. When I really took a look at the peripheral, I knew there was no way I really wanted to play regular keys, because it just seemed like it would be boring as all get out. That being said, I wish I hadn't taken keyboarding so long ago... and that I hadn't stopped going and failed out.
Also, basically the keyboard is the equivalent to something like C1 through C3, for people who know their keyboard/piano. Though one thing that bothers me is that you can't use ANY octave while playing. If a note shows up as C2, you must play it as C2. C1 won't cut it. I was fairly disappointed in this.
The Pro Keys trainer was also great, actually. Some of the scales were actually kinda difficult to get through - it really WAS like my old keyboarding class. I haven't messed with Pro Keys during many songs at the moment, so I can't really say which songs have been fantastic for it, though I have definitely heard potential in some songs that we've played so far.
Pro Drums
Pro Drums sounds pretty awesome. Unfortunately, I don't drum. And for the most part, the people I have drum for me haven't been using the cymbals, so I don't think anyone has attempted the pro drums mode yet.Vocals
For the most part, vocals are still the same, but there are definitely some differences. First off, and foremost, is that sometimes the vocalists don't even get scored. I haven't experienced this yet, but from my understanding, in All Instrument Mode, or anytime a keyboard is present, a vocalist won't get scored. Also in All Instrument Mode, a vocalist is stuck at Easy difficulty and cannot use Overdrive. Suffice to say, I don't play All Instrument Mode.One of the problems people have been having with vox since release is getting Overdrive to work, even outside of All Instrument Mode. People have complained about screaming into the mic, to no avail. Many of these people mention that they can't get their Overdrive to deploy until the end of the song.
Another problem with vox is that in this iteration of the game, there is no mic sensitivity control. We still can control track volume, and mic volume for up to three mics, but no mic sensitivity. However, something I find interesting is how now you can almost constantly see how sensitive your mic is from the input bar that is above the vocalist's mini-menu most of the time.
Finally, one more issue I have been finding with vox is that while some of the songs that they have added are GREAT for harmonies... they are difficult for solos in that when we hear the song, apparently we hear the harmony overpower the melody. A great example of this is Bohemian Rhapsody. Or, at least the way they charted it. As a gold star expert vocalist, and someone who banged their head to that song since the days of Wayne's World like many others, I was surprised at how much trouble I had with that song.
UI and Gameplay
I agree with JJWeatherman that the changes that have been made for solos and 4x multipliers are confusing, especially to RB veterans. I also agree on the unison bonuses when playing by yourself. I didn't even realize that was in there, honestly. There are some things that JJ missed on the in-song UI though that I want to touch on.I liked how over on the left side of your screen, where the crowd meter is, you have the Join Now options for other players. However, because of the way it's set up, I guess I thought it would be more like Guitar Hero, where you can jump right in without interrupting the rest of the band as they play. Unfortunately, that's not the case. The entire band will have the song paused for them as the new rocker joins. But this brings up one of the changes that I like that they've made - When the song has been paused, once someone unpauses, the song "rewinds" a bit, so that people can get back into where they were without missing a whole bunch of notes. This was definitely a needed change.
So Out-Of-Song UI stuff... I agree that the library overhaul was completely needed, even though there are still a few kinks to it.
A couple of the other changes I'm really digging come from the end-of-song UI. First off, there's the fact that we can see each person's individual score now during band quickplay. Although I think my husband and friends are starting to get tired of seeing me gold star 90% of the songs we play together. But one of the other additions to that UI that is very cool is that we can now see our leaderboard status immediately.
Rocker Customization
From what I have seen, creating my own toons, and watching my husband and friends create toons - chicks got screwed over. It's become fairly difficult to create a female toon and not have her face looking all messed up, no matter how much you tweak her face. But I do like the new proportions sliders. I am a bit disappointed that we lost out on our "Hometown" and "Attitude." One final thing that bugs me about this part of character customization is that there is still no damn curly hair! The closest I was able to get before was "Lolita" which was at least wavy. Now there isn't even a wavy hairstyle. There's either dreads, fro, or straight hair. I usually like to make my vocalist look fairly close to how I look, but that just isn't even flying this time. I have yet to post my character's pic as JJWeatherman has. I keep hoping that somehow they'll just fix the damn photo creator from the website. But I'll just have to post my toon's pic soon.As for the new way to get clothes and stuff... I'm not sure that I mind it. In some ways I do, but in some ways I don't. Then again, it seems like I've opened up a ton of stuff so far. But at the same time, I'm not going to be pleased about playing Pro Drums to open that stuff up.
I also like the stand-ins, and liked it in the last game. In response to JJWeatherman... I think its possible that the order of the standins might determine the instruments, but I also haven't messed with that a whole lot yet.
Log in to comment