RudeCubes

First Zelda I played and beat so it's the best

LankyMario

I wish Paper Mario 2's Audience would make a return. It added a nice randomness to some battles than only got more exciting as your 'stage' got bigger. Worrying about stage pyro, hoping a Shy Guy ends up knocking down a light on the right guy, and wowing the crowd with STYLISH!! moves for more star power. I'd love to see it come back and be expanded upon.

Man, no one ever talks about the Magical Quest games!

@dudelongcouch: That's probably why. I love the original Chibi Robo but it was kind of niche.