First of all, thank you all for the advice.  This is going up quick, since i want to try to be able to gift the winner during the sale. 
 
My scoring went something like this: 
I gave each answer an overall "rating" with different components weighted differently.  For example, recommended a game I will buy was worth a weight of "5" while recommended a game I already own was worth a weight of "1".  This does not mean you get 1 point for typing up each game I already own.  If you wrote in coherent english, I gave a weight of 4 or so, if you gave more than one reason, a weight of 6, if you mentioned price, weight of 3, mentioned specs/performance, weight of 5.  I also really liked people who wrote "I see you have X game, so you might like Y game" and those who mentioned something I had never heard of. 
 
Here is the unsorted list: 

@ch13696: 2 

 @jellyfish_gsus: 1

@CowMuffins: 2

@Mikemcn: 7

@moose: 5

@keenblaze: 17

@ahmad_metallic: -50

@masterofpenguins_zell: 10

@wolf_blitzer85: 5

@tehjames: 8

@havox: 5

@onemanfreakshow: 7

@hitmanagent47: 1

@kamikaze_tutor: 5

@cap123: 5