Should I buy the HD version, community?

Avatar image for jamakan_inc
#1 Posted by Jamakan_Inc (100 posts) -

Hey guys, so I'm seriously considering getting this. I don't own any other copies of it (well, technically my girlfriend has the Wii version, which is good,) but I'd rather play it with a 360 controller. Is the HD port really that bad? Does it handle like RE5 on the 360? What say you, community? WHAT SAY YOU? Also, thanks in advance for your time, I know these arent exactly the most interesting threads.

Avatar image for darthorange
#2 Edited by DarthOrange (4178 posts) -

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

Avatar image for hector
#3 Posted by Hector (3547 posts) -

@DarthOrange said:

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

Is Assignment Ada included?

Avatar image for sackmanjones
#4 Posted by Sackmanjones (5513 posts) -
@Hector said:

@DarthOrange said:

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

Is Assignment Ada included?

I believe so
Avatar image for spazmaster666
#5 Edited by spazmaster666 (2112 posts) -

@DarthOrange said:

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

That's the main reason why I didn't like Resident Evil 4. I hate games that force you to use the left stick for aiming. I don't understand why in an HD remake they couldn't allow you to aim with the right stick and move with the left stick. I mean they obviously adapted the controls for the Wii version, so why not the 360/PS3 version?

Avatar image for countershock
#6 Posted by CounterShock (436 posts) -

You should just play the Wii version if it's available to you. The HD versions are fine, there is a weird thing with the Ganados voices sounding like they're coming out of a Wii remote. Besides that, the Wii remote is the best way to control that game.

Avatar image for zacagawea
#7 Posted by Zacagawea (1678 posts) -

@spazmaster666 said:

@DarthOrange said:

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

That's the main reason why I didn't like Resident Evil 4. I hate games that force you to use the left stick for aiming. I don't understand why in an HD remake they couldn't allow you to aim with the right stick and move with the left stick. I mean they obviously adapted the controls for the Wii version, so why not the 360/PS3 version?

Because it's a lazy and quick cash grab

Avatar image for captain_clayman
#8 Posted by captain_clayman (3349 posts) -

@spazmaster666 said:

@DarthOrange said:

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

That's the main reason why I didn't like Resident Evil 4. I hate games that force you to use the left stick for aiming. I don't understand why in an HD remake they couldn't allow you to aim with the right stick and move with the left stick. I mean they obviously adapted the controls for the Wii version, so why not the 360/PS3 version?

whaaaat i thought there was a way to change the options to use the right stick? i swear that's what they said on the quicklook.

Avatar image for hizang
#9 Posted by Hizang (9358 posts) -

The PSN/XBLA version is probbaly the best version of that game.

Avatar image for spazmaster666
#10 Edited by spazmaster666 (2112 posts) -

@captain_clayman said:

whaaaat i thought there was a way to change the options to use the right stick? i swear that's what they said on the quicklook.

You can remap the aim and shoot buttons to the bumpers but not remap the actual aiming to the right stick. Baffling yes, but true.

Avatar image for darthorange
#11 Posted by DarthOrange (4178 posts) -

@Hector said:

@DarthOrange said:

I just finished the PS3 version this morning and honestly it is fine, some people just like to bitch about graphics, but the gameplay is fine. It is a little different from RE5 in terms of handling, but over all it's basically the same thing. Biggest difference is that you aim with the left stick instead of the right stick (at least on the PS3 version). I say go for it, your in for a real treat if you haven't played it before, and even if you have, it still holds up well.

Is Assignment Ada included?

Yes it is.

Avatar image for soapy86
#12 Posted by Soapy86 (2738 posts) -

I actually just bought the 360 version a few days ago. It's great.

Avatar image for darthorange
#13 Posted by DarthOrange (4178 posts) -
Avatar image for mrklorox
#14 Posted by MrKlorox (11142 posts) -

Every version is fucked up in the control department, so it really doesn't matter.

Avatar image for re_player1
#15 Posted by RE_Player1 (8010 posts) -

I would say it's worth it. I got the PS3 version for $10, Playstation Plus discount the first week it was out, and had a blast even though I blasted my way through because I played it to death on Gamecube. For someone playing it for the first time I'm say $20 is a good price and I believe it comes with 1000 achievement points because it's technically in the Games on Demand section.

Avatar image for blatantninja23
#16 Posted by BlatantNinja23 (931 posts) -

I have it on 360 and its fine... but i also actually preferred playing the wii version.

Avatar image for willthemagicasian
#17 Posted by WilltheMagicAsian (1548 posts) -

@msavo: Well it did have a retail release in Japan and Europe, just not in the North America.

Avatar image for apparatus_unearth
#18 Posted by Apparatus_Unearth (3687 posts) -

I'm playing it for the first time via the HD version, it's so good.

Avatar image for walkertr77
#19 Posted by WalkerTR77 (1810 posts) -

@WilltheMagicAsian: No retail release in the UK though.

I've been wanting to buy it for a while. I had 640 points on my account, thought I would buy 1200 and get it. Turns out that would put me 40 points short. Will probably just buy it with £15 of real money at some point rather than with Brad Bucks.

Avatar image for jasonr86
#20 Edited by JasonR86 (10178 posts) -

@Jamakan_Inc:

I actually own this game three different ways (Gamecube, Wii, and now 360). It's probably my second favorite version behind the Wii version (primarily due to the Wii's controls). It's certainly the best looking version. It looks like an upscaled Gamecube game. That's not necessarily a bad thing. But it doesn't look like a modern 360 game. The controls are fine. It's similar to the Gamecube version (though that doesn't necessarily help you since you didn't play that game). It's similar to RE 5 but there's no strafing. It controls fine. It's a little clunky but all versions of this game are clunky. If you could handle the movement controls on the Wii then you'll be able to handle the movement controls on the 360. They are identical. Only the aiming controls are different (on the 360 you hold a button, stand in one spot, and aim with either the left or right stick).

EDIT:

I was wrong. You can't aim with the right stick. Again, this is just like the Gamecube version. Some people are ok with this, like me, others are not. I think it works just fine though.

Online

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.