Coming from a submissions moderator:
There is a relatively small number of submission moderators right now, and the queue is huge. I understand you guys are writing your fingers off; but you need to understand that once you submit your change/article/addition - it sits behind a long line of other submissions. Some submissions get rejected because they aren't correct, or they are plagarized. Some get removed because they are redundant and someone already made a better post about it. People need to stop worrying about points - this website is GROWING. Wikipedia wasn't built in a day, and niether was Rome.
Why do you think Jeff, Vinny and Ryan didn't say "screw user submited" let's just copy and paste from wiki and other gaming websites - and start off with every game known to man. Because.... there is no fun in that, and there is no effort and comradry in that. We are GB and this website is our pride and joy (at least mine). Stop being in a rush to get things out the door, and please stop being in a rush to raise your point count. I think the point count is what is making things stack up. People are too eager to be #1.
It's a process guys, so please bear with us on this. Most of us spend our free time aproving submissions, but more keep coming. We're not saying it's a bad thing, but the things really backed up right now and it seems like some people in the community don't understand this. So please, be patient and keep doing what you're doing, and we'll keep doing what we're doing and Giant Bomb will blow up. (No pun intended) :)
To clarify a few things....
amen. Seriously people need to lay off of the submission criticizm. they have gotten over a 100k submissions so its going to take a very long time
"there should never have been a point count, stuff like that all ways causes problems.
"
if there wasn't do you think there would be many people trying to help build the database?
A couple more points to add to this line of discussion, from another subs moderator:
- It's been mentioned that you should do an advanced search before you suggest new pages, which I would like to re-emphasize, but please also note that the search engine hiccups a bit if your search query has a colon in it, so if you're submitting, for instance, Resistance: Retribution, search up Resistance instead of the whole title.
- Please, please, please put down what type of change you are making in the box at the bottom. Are you relating similar games? Are you adding games to a character? If you're making changes to article text, what section is it from? These things really help us prioritize and streamline when approving submissions. "Adding information" doesn't really help us, because hopefully that's what you're all doing! =)
- I will re-emphasize that we'd like Giant Bomb to be fresh and original. If people want information from Wikipedia, they'll go there. Let's build our own world here, yeah?
- Finally, please be patient with us. You're going to get a lot of stuff rejected because in 3+ days' time, other people are going to come up with the same characters to add and similar games to relate and all these other wonderful things as you do. As Jax said, it's a process, we're doing our best to make it work, and we're all together on this.
Hang in there and keep up the good work, everyone! Remember to not be bitter about points, they're just a number. I'm constantly amazed at what everyone is coming up with (someone please fill in the grass concept page we just approved with ridiculous minutiae)!
"GMOLE said:"How would the crew at Giantbomb know someone copied and paste from Wikipedia?
"
Easy, we Google everything we get.
"
Wait, are you telling me you are part of the Giantbomb crew???
you said "we", so that must mean you are working there with them....
How come it doesn't say Staff or Moderator at the bottom of your avatar?
"Clint said:Take a look at my new blog entry for some clarification on this subject."GMOLE said:"How would the crew at Giantbomb know someone copied and paste from Wikipedia?
"
Easy, we Google everything we get.
"
Wait, are you telling me you are part of the Giantbomb crew???
you said "we", so that must mean you are working there with them....
How come it doesn't say Staff or Moderator at the bottom of your avatar?"
I'm sure you guys know this already, but I'm going to say it anyway. No one is making threads saying "I know how hard you guys are working on our submissions, but I summited a page two and a half days ago, and it still isn't up. I would like to say that's fine, and you guys take all the time you need," but a lot of us are thinking it. Don't let a few impatient forum users get you down. Some people just like to bitch. : )
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment