Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb Review

123 Comments

Dead Rising 2 Review

3
  • X360
  • PC

Dead Rising 2 comes with a long list of unfortunate problems, but if you're the type to look past those issues and love a good challenge, this game is actually awesome.


 You'll find some firearms around, both traditional and crazy.
 You'll find some firearms around, both traditional and crazy.
There are multiple ways to play Dead Rising 2. Some of them are simply amazing, giving you tons of time to wander around malls and casinos, busting up zombies with a variety of weapons that are incredibly satisfying to use. At the other end of the spectrum, Dead Rising 2 can also be a tight, time-focused game that's more about running from one place to the next and ensuring that you're in the right place at the right time, with the right weapons to defeat whatever boss-style encounter the game has lined up for you. Dead Rising 2 runs the full range from frustration to fun, but there's more good than bad to be had here.

The bulk of the bad parts in Dead Rising 2 comes at you when you're trying to play through the story or complete side missions. That's when you'll be dealing with survivors--the other humans that have somehow made it through the initial wave of the zombie attack without being bitten. If you played the first Dead Rising, you'll remember the survivors as ineffective dopes that were hard to save since they weren't good enough to keep the zombies at bay and follow you to safety. In Dead Rising 2, the survivors are more resilient and occasionally they're better fighters, too. Still, you'll run into cases where two armed survivors get caught in each others' crossfire or spots where they just sort of don't seem to keep up as well as they were five seconds before. They're still annoying... but they're way less of a game-breaker this time around.

The other type of human you encounter while running around beautiful Fortune City is the psychopath. These guys are usually regular humans that have snapped under the strain of the zombie outbreak, and these can vary from a children's television star wearing a giant mask, roller skates, and homemade flamethrowers to a military man who's lost his team and his mind. After stumbling into one or two of these fights while taking on side missions, I did my best to just avoid them, because I didn't enjoy any of them at all. These battles don't feel like you're actually taking on a new and unique foe. Instead, they feel like barely functional combat puzzles where the main solution is to exploit the AI in one way or another. Facing an armed opponent? Run around a pillar as he gives chase, and then club him with a spiked bat when you "catch up" to him. Facing a guy on roller skates with two homemade flamethrowers? Well, in that case you... actually, I never beat that guy. It just didn't seem worth it, so I found a different side mission.

 There are outdoor areas, but most of your time is spent in malls and casinos.
 There are outdoor areas, but most of your time is spent in malls and casinos.
So, you might be asking, if that's the worst of Dead Rising 2, why are you still semi-positive about the overall experience? It's the setting, some of the characters, and the open nature of your trek through the story that makes Dead Rising 2 work. If you essentially abandon the "facts" of the story missions, you can spend all of your game time building ridiculous combo weapons and taking out your aggressions on a shambling horde of slow-moving zombies or the occasional looter. Since Fortune City is a casino town, you can even gamble to earn a little extra cash, and that money can be used to unlock vehicles. This is a great use of money, since the vehicles stay unlocked for multiple playthroughs.

Again, if you've played Dead Rising, this won't be a surprise, but Dead Rising 2 is built to be played numerous times. So much so, in fact, that every time you die or fail a case, the game gives you the option to simply restart the entire game with your bankroll and character level intact. This means that you'll become more powerful over time, and that power can be used to make the early parts of the game even easier. It also gives you another option when dealing with the game's tougher moments--you can always just start over and grind out more levels to get more inventory slots, health blocks, and attack strength.

If all of this sounds a bit weird, that's OK. Dead Rising 2 is a pretty weird game. But at the heart of it is a relatively normal guy named Chuck Greene. Chuck's an ex-motorcross racer with a daughter who needs a shot of Zombrex every 24 hours or else she'll turn into a zombie. To get money for the constant supply of drugs, Chuck gets on a pay-per-view cross of The Running Man and American Gladiators called Terror Is Reality. In it, contestants kill zombies for sport. But after his winning performance, there's a huge explosion and zombies flood the arena and the nearby malls and casinos that surround it. The military will show up in three days, but that's not exactly a good thing, as someone's released a tape to the media showing Chuck Greene (or a man in his TIR outfit) planting the bomb that let all the zombies in. This gives Chuck three days to clear his name by figuring out what's really going on in Fortune City, while saving additional survivors and procuring more of the increasingly scarce Zombrex to keep his daughter human. In other words, you've got a lot of time pressure to deal with.

Dead Rising 2 eases up some of that pressure by offering you multiple save slots--the first game only had one--which gives you a way to avoid situations where you save your game in an impossible-to-fix situation, such as right before time expires on a critical mission. While some might bemoan the mission timers, it feels like a vital part of the game, and that tension drives all of the action. Getting around and killing the average zombies that attempt to block your path is a breeze, especially if you stop by one of the many maintenance rooms to do a little crafting.

Probably the most common combo weapon of them all.
Probably the most common combo weapon of them all.
Crafting weapons and using them is, by far, the coolest part of Dead Rising 2. You'll find all sorts of different things lying around the world that you can pick up and use, from assault rifles to rolled-up newspapers. But some items are marked with a wrench, noting that they can be combined with another item to form something that's usually more deadly. Some of these combos are basic and logical--taking a baseball bat and combining it with a box of nails gets you a spiked baseball bat, for example. But the weapons get weirder and weirder from there, such as the Freedom Bear, which is a machine gun duct-taped to a toy robot bear that normally lights up and smiles when he sees you. After the process is complete, you can set the bear out like a sentry and he'll fire at enemies that enter his sight line. Then there's absolutely devastating stuff like a fire axe strapped to a sledge hammer, making for an extremely heavy, slow-moving weapon that murders any zombie it comes into contact with with a great mix of blunt force and sharp death. And what happens when you combine a flashlight with gems? You get a laser sword, of course. Figuring out these combinations and using them is more entertaining than just about anything the story missions have to offer. As you level up and scour the world, you'll acquire combo cards that tell you what things can be combined and, if you have the card, you'll get twice as many prestige points, which is the game's equivalent to experience points.

The PC version of Dead Rising 2 looks the best and has the most resolution options. It also has Games For Windows Live support, which is nice for fans of Microsoft's achievement system. The Xbox 360 version of the game has some fairly noticeable drops in frame rate, but still looks just fine most of the time. The 360 version also lets you import your level (up to level five) from the downloadable prequel, Case Zero. This will give you a bit of a head start in the 360 version, but getting through those first five levels doesn't take very long at all. So PS3 and PC owners that can't import characters aren't really missing out on much.

Money isn't really much of an object in Dead Rising 2, anyway. The game has a multiplayer mode based on the reality violence show that opens the single-player. It's essentially a four-player minigame collection that involves various ways to murder zombies. Money earned in ranked games can be funneled back into your single-player saves, but beyond that, the minigames aren't much fun and shouldn't be considered a primary draw. The game also has online co-op, letting players jump into your single-player game and assist. This is a fun option, especially for the joining player, since it isn't your playthrough. Time has less of a meaning when you're not messing up your own save, so you can just freely follow the host player and bust heads at will. But the design of the co-op feels like it fell out of a PlayStation 2 game. Joining players also play as Chuck Greene, and the story's cutscenes don't evolve to account for the second player, either. It makes the whole thing feel a little thrown together.

 You'll have a lot of options for changing--or removing your clothes.
 You'll have a lot of options for changing--or removing your clothes.
The groans of the zombie horde and the sound effects when you clobber them with your various items are all very well done. Splattering zombies with a blunt object sounds appropriately wet and disgusting. The cutscenes usually have pretty good dialogue, though for a game set in Nevada, it's easy to hear Canadian speech mannerisms coming out of the characters here and there. That's not inherently bad, but it sure serves as a constant reminder that most of the heavy lifting for Dead Rising 2's development was done in Vancouver, not Osaka.

Dead Rising 2's kooky structure and occasionally open nature gives it a lot of appeal across many different types of players, but the people who truly love Dead Rising 2 will all have a few things in common. They'll appreciate a challenge, even when it seems like you're occasionally fighting the game mechanics, rather than the boss fight. They'll enjoy playing through a game multiple times, each with a slightly different objective. And they'll probably enjoy running through thousands upon thousands of easy-to-kill zombies. It's also very divisive. Plenty of people will hate the way the game uses time to force a layer of tension onto everything they do. Others will hate the lack of an autosave system, even though adding one of those would inherently change the entire game. Me, I wish the game had better inventory control and an item storage system to allow you to really explore all of your weapon options. But it's the other stuff--the still messy survivor AI and poorly built boss battles--that really mars the Dead Rising 2 experience. It's not an impossible game to love, but as with the first game, you'll have to look past a lot of blemishes to find happiness.
Jeff Gerstmann on Google+

123 Comments

Avatar image for yakov456
yakov456

2021

Forum Posts

133

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By yakov456

Critiquing someone's review of a game, always hilarious to me.

Avatar image for chaser324
chaser324

9415

Forum Posts

14945

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 15

Edited By chaser324  Moderator
@kratier: 
I know there are definitely some bugs in there right now, but those should eventually get patched. Is there anything inherent in the design of Civ V that is broken? Personally, I don't think so.
Avatar image for ravensword
ravensword

4330

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 1

Edited By ravensword

huh, does PS3 version have these FPS drops and all that? Or did Jeff not play that version?
Avatar image for agentboolen
agentboolen

1995

Forum Posts

12

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

Edited By agentboolen

A 3 seems a little bit on the harsh side.  I would have easily thought it would have gotten a 4.  It must have been Jeff's time of the month.  Sure I know they didn't really change up the formula that much, they kind of took the if it aint broke don't fix it route, while actually fixing the complaints from some of the gamers that felt the 1st game was to hard.  So I understand why he gave it a 3, but damn he must have been in a bad mood that day.  For me I would easily give it a 5, its just brainless, addicting fun.    

Avatar image for faint
Faint

837

Forum Posts

46

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 7

Edited By Faint
@RE_Player92:  its a real shame as the Japanese games industry used to put out some amazing titles. i can recently recall the creator of kingdom hearts, tetsuya nomura, being interviewed and the interviewer asked him if in birth by sleep they were fixing the camera issues the series seems to maintain. his reply was something along the lines of "when im making video games im not thinking about what people don't like". this is in contrast to bioware who almost took offense to some of the complaints about mass effect 1 and spent endless hours trying to fix every valid complaint for a better sequel. the sad thing is that it's probably not going to change. ff13 was a failure, but they still sold a massive load of copies due to it being a main title in the series, so they probably aren't even remotely aware that so many people didn't like the game. if only japan would learn!
Avatar image for sambambo
Sambambo

3173

Forum Posts

1009

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 9

Edited By Sambambo
@KinjiroSSD said:
" @Rasgueado said:
" @SuperSambo said:
" I enjoyed the xbla title, but that was enough Dead Rising to last me awhile. I want to enjoy them, but I dont have any fun while playing... "
Uh... could you expand on that idea please?  "
Perhaps he enjoys them conceptually but not actually playing them. I'm kinda the same way with RTSs. "
Yup, exactly this. It seems like such an amazing idea, but design choices have just sucked the fun out for me.
Avatar image for balfas
Balfas

30

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Balfas

I agree with alof of Jeff's review. The weird game structure and frustrating boss battle are reason that the first game never appealed to me. But I am really enjoying DR2 and that is purely down to case zero. Case zero is a perfect gateway into the dead rising world and its structure and lifts the lid on this confusing but really enjoyable game.  

Avatar image for scytalezero
ScytaleZero

16

Forum Posts

60

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By ScytaleZero
@Death_Burnout:  Perhaps you are unaware of this somehow, but different people can like different things.  I played DR1 and the clock is what killed it for me, so I know I don't like it.  That doesn't mean you can't love the clock and I'm not suggesting you shouldn't.
 
Anyway, I already play a game where I have to closely monitor a clock and get to certain places at specific times.  I meet various characters there and try to accomplish my missions.  Thing is, I already play this game 40 hours a week and they pay me to do it.  For me personally, I don't want that time pressure in my free time. 
Avatar image for rocospi
Rocospi

271

Forum Posts

52

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Rocospi

"Canadian speech mannerisms", what? 
I've lived in Vancouver for 10 years, and I can't tell a difference between a Canadian and an American person talking. So...what speech mannerisms are you talking about? Like "aboot" and "eh?", is that it?

Avatar image for raineko
Raineko

450

Forum Posts

840

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Raineko

You can start all over AND KEEP YOUR STATS?!  
Why didn´t I know that. :(

Avatar image for a_faceless_name
A_Faceless_Name

172

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By A_Faceless_Name

Very fair review. The game is a few minor tweaks away from being a real standout.  Co-op is a ton of fun, and probably more fun that playing your own game.

Avatar image for luthorcrow
luthorcrow

195

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By luthorcrow


Even with it's flaws 3 stars feels a bit low but I understand the rational behind the score.

For me, I started playing the full game after playing Zero and hearing Jeff complain about the boss fights on the podcast. As a result I avoided all of the fights on my first playthrough until I reached level 15 a boss fight you could not avoid.  I then restarted my game. I got a little lucky on my first boss fight because a random internet player, yes a random internet player that actually was helpful, joined my game after several escort missions helped me beat the "Biggest Fan" (nutty protestor) boss. Together we barely took him down. After that game session I did fudge it a bit watched a YouTube video for "Taste Likes Chicken" "Everybody Loves Slappy".  After that the boss fights made a lot more sense and the two chicks that you have to fight and the wedding chapel boss were pretty straight forward.

If there are two things I think they should fix, patch or change in the next game, there should be a savepoint right before each boss fight.  The fights all take some preparation (you need good food: mixed drinks or meat, etc.) then be a little kind and give us a savepoint right before a tough fight. Or at least conveniently put a bathroom near every boss.

The second thing would be load times. This may a tough one and I will admit I playing from disk so maybe load times would be better if I installed it to the drive.

I guess also agree with Jeff that some kind of presistent storage box would be nice in the mechanical rooms.  At the very least it would be experimenting with the various less used combo weapons more fun.


The rest is all good as long as you understand Dead Rising series is bit tough and different bread of game.    

Avatar image for silverdoe
silverdoe

12

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By silverdoe

 Did he play the same game as me? Sounds liked he just wrote this off after forgetting to save the game & had to start all over again. That's maybe the only flaw! lol

Avatar image for egocheck616
EgoCheck616

820

Forum Posts

37

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By EgoCheck616
@silverdoe said:
"  Did he play the same game as me? Sounds liked he just wrote this off after forgetting to save the game & had to start all over again. That's maybe the only flaw! lol "
Agreed.
Avatar image for meierthered
MeierTheRed

6084

Forum Posts

1701

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MeierTheRed
@Raineko said:
" You can start all over AND KEEP YOUR STATS?!  Why didn´t I know that. :( "
 How could you not know? it even says so in the game when you die.
Avatar image for justicen7
JusticeN7

18

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By JusticeN7

Nice review, never played the first one and i don't think ill be getting this game 

Avatar image for james_ahlschwede
James_Ahlschwede

3

Forum Posts

11

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By James_Ahlschwede

I'd been thinking about getting the first game, but decided to hold out for the sequel -- the Bombcast + this review convinced me that Dead Rising 2 is three things: 1) better than the original, 2) awesome 3) not necessarily fun.  
 
I think I'm going to give it a pass. Hope they do a 3rd that gets it right.

Avatar image for zenwork
Zenwork

64

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Zenwork

Not a very good game, same issues as the first one, the single player experience is frustrating, however the multi player is fun.

Avatar image for juggaloacidman
JuggaloAcidman

427

Forum Posts

49

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 4

Edited By JuggaloAcidman

I'm kinda wondering if Jeff played a different zombie game and thought it was Dead Rising 2.. The only problem he listed that I experienced was survivors shooting each other... Other than that, all of the problems Jeff listed were a non issue for me... I live in Reno Nevada... I didn't notice a single Canadian "speech mannerisms". We must sound like Canadians here!!! Also, Dead Rising 2 might have been a touch on the easy side for me. So all this talk of frustration and challenge is kind of confusing. I've played through the game almost twice now... No challenge for me. The fight with TK at the end is the hardest part... 3 trys. Co-op feels like PS2? Apparently you haven't played Halo Co-op or Fable 2 Co-op... Stories don't account for the second player most of the time... Thats just the way it is. I kinda wonder if Jeff EVEN PLAYED DEAD RISING 2. If the review wasn't titled "Dead Rising 2" I would have thought it was a review for another game. Sorry Jeff, huge miss for me.
Avatar image for moneylaunderer
MoneyLaunderer

21

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MoneyLaunderer

I'm having a much more entertaining time with this over the original. I guess I just like the combo cards and I honestly like Chuck more than Frank. Hoping for a Dead Rising 3.

Avatar image for saga
Saga

190

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 1

Edited By Saga

I should get this

Avatar image for tobiass
Tobiass

160

Forum Posts

16

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Gertsman hates menus. This game has you going through so many.

Avatar image for tobiass
Tobiass

160

Forum Posts

16

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Tobiass

Pretty much my opinion too. Like the first, unless you're some sort of gaming savant, you're better off tossing a coin on what you want to do next - the main story or the side missions? It's a hell of a lot more streamlined than the first, though, and a lot purtier.

In the QL you had trouble joining a TIR match on the 360, but did you have the same issues with PSN?

If it's bad on XBL it's going to be worse on PSN.