I really like your write up, great analysis of the movies!
I want to say my peace about why I believe the fight between gendo and shinji looked so bad toward the end of the movie. I believe this is 100% intentional, for a couple reasons.
I agree completely, that when I was watching it initially I thought, wow this looks extremely mo-capped and not blended in the scene at all, and they aren't even fighting in the way Eva's typically do - this was more of a giant monster fight than anything seen in the show before. Then, it's revealed the Evas are are on a movie/tv set. This is a reference to the end of the eva tv series, where the motif around all the characters confessions at the end is via a tv or theater set. Then we transition to Shinji reversing his role from the original ending of the series, and helping everyone better understand their own characters flaws so to speak
Anyway, that's at least why that particular scene worked for me.
As for the Gendo and Shinji talk and why it sort of fell flat. Well, I think a sort of unique aspect of 3.0+1.0 is that it not only is finishing the story of evangelion, but I believe it is also adding additional context to the whole series. I know that the story of the original series differs quite a bit from the movies, but I think the way both narratives work together is quite fascinating. So, when Gendo and Shinji are talking, we don't just have the context from the movies, but also the original show. We know quite a bit about the relationship since we learned a lot about it through Ritsuko and other characters. However, I *think* this is the first time Shinji and Gendo talk explicitly to each other about the reasons why Gendo did what he did.
To me all three endings of the show essential are different ways of coming to the same conclusion. But, 3.0+1.0 offers us an Additional Ending (Impact???): the one we finally see where Shinji and all the characters are free.
Hopefully at least a little of this makes sense lol. I watched all the movies over the course of 2 days, and I probably need to watch them again if I want to get any deeper meaning out of them.
There's some really great moments in the last movie (the whole first half is phenomenal). And I'm glad this is all over and we can finally say: Goodbye, All of Evangelion.
Log in to comment