What is your favorite game of all time?

Shadow of the Colossus.

I can't choose, I could never choose!

Shadow of the Colossus or Link to the Past, I can't decide.

I guess I like worlds that pull me in.  Oh shit, EverQuest.  In like 98-2001 before there were a load of bad expansions.  That was probably the most fun I've ever had with a game - but you can't ever replay it and put it to the test of time like something like LttP.

im tempted to go with the prdictable Modern Warfare 2 but i actually think it has to  be Shadow of the Colossus, that game was something special