Up - A good or a bad animation movie?

What were your thoughts after seeing the movie Up?
 
Did you like it?
 
Or not?
 
What did really make an impression on you?
 
For me though the beginning is really cool and emotional, but the movie is too fantastic to take it as seriously as to take something out of it. 
 
It was a bit overhyped in my opinion.
 
And for you?

I heard it was simply amazing.

That movie was b-e-a-u-tiful. I really enjoyed it thoroughly.

The video montage near the beginning was a big downer for me, the rest was sexual chocolate.

That movie was astounding. Pixar was at their best, hype be damned.

It's Pixar. It's hard to hate any of their movies.

errrrr ahhhhh maybe i saw the wrong movie... 
 
:p

Great film.
 
The beginning and ending are phenomenal achievements in animated story telling.
The middle is a entertaining buddy action-adventure comedy, but nothing extremely special.
 
I don't think it was overhyped because the people I talked to enjoyed it a ton, but weren't blown away by it.
 
As I stand, I think it's the best animated film I've seen this year (though I need to see Fantastic Mr. Fox among others before I can confirm that) & one of Pixar's best,  but it's not one of the best animated films of all time...at least not yet.
 
Though I plan to see the film again sometime soon, so I can see whether or not my opinion changes.

That movie surprised me. It was quite touching, especially the beginning.

I really enjoyed it. I can't think of a single movie or short feature that Pixar has done that I haven't enjoyed.

Pixar at its best yet again

It's good.

" It's Pixar. It's hard to hate any of their movies. "

I thought it was one of Pixar's best, which is saying a lot.

Neither. 
 
 
IT WAS FAN-TRIPLE-TASTIC!

I thought it was amazing. I really enjoyed it.

I think it's the best film Pixar has made... It deals with some heavy themes and I  was really quite touched by it... I didn't care too much for all the shenanigans  in the jungle but it is a kids movie and where most cartoons has silly gags around a superfluous story, this movie used the gags in a setting with a very powerful message.

I've only heard good things about it.

Wall-e was better, but this is still one of the greatest movies of the decade, to say the least.

Haven't seen it yet, but I have heard great things about it.

It was good. 
 
Not as good as movie critics thought, though.

One of my favourite films of 2009 easily.

It was good, though overrated. I had very high expectations (97% metascore, people raving about how fantastic it was), and I was disappointed. It was a generic kid-friendly family movie, albeit a good one, but not groundbreaking in any respect.

I would like to find the few critics who gave Up a bad review (Stephanie Zackareck, I'm looking at you!!!) and kick them in their puss-bleeding twats! 
 
@extremeradical said:

" Wall-e was better, but this is still one of the greatest movies of the decade, to say the least. "

It was surprisingly hilarious. Pixar seemed to be less funny and more touchy to me these days. So being able to laugh a lot made me enjoy a great deal.

" I would like to find the few critics who gave Up a bad review (Stephanie Zackareck, I'm looking at you!!!) and kick them in their puss-bleeding twats! 
 
@extremeradical said:

" Wall-e was better, but this is still one of the greatest movies of the decade, to say the least. "

I think Wall-E is a COMPLETELY different kind of movie, though. "

Good...but definitely not my favorite pixar movie.  
 
The story just didn't seem...full?

That movie was fantastic. Simply stunning.

I saw it with my nephew, we both enjoyed it. 

Up is a great film. Certainly one of Pixar's strongest. You can tell that they have been very inspired by Miyazaki (Howl's Moving Castle specifically). And that's a big positive as far as I'm concerned. It's a sweet tale.

I thought it was great but one of Pixar's worst in my opinion. The first half was amazing with his wife and all. Although I thought that many of the jokes were like something I'd find in Dreamworks movie.

" ... I thought that many of the jokes were like something I'd find in Dreamworks movie. "

I did feel the 2nd half was weak when compared to some other of there movies but it was still nothing short of steller, its rare that a animated movie can get you teary eyed the beginning got pretty rough.

I thought it was astoundingly good. Pixar never seems to fail to make meaningfully, ageless and thoroughly entertaining films.

I loved it, one of the best animation movies I have ever seen.

Up was an amazing movie to me. Pixar managed to wow me twice recently with Wall-E and Up, both of which rank right up there with Toy Story and Toy Story 2 as my favorite Pixar movies.

I'm not sure if it is one of Pixar's strongest movies, but it's pretty tight.

I think Up deserves it's place as Best Picture.
 
Best Animated Film has too much a stigma.

10. Cars
9. Wall-E 
8. Finding Nemo
7. Ratatouille 
6. A Bugs Life
5. Monsters inc.
4. The Incredibles
3. Toy Story 
2. UP
1. Toy Story 2
 
This is where I would put UP in my top 10 pixar movies.

i thought it was good too, but i also think it would've been much better if the story was about the journey there instead of them just cutting straight to the destination

It's a really good movie.

Up was extremely average, Wall-E was only slightly better.

If a movie can make me tear up more than once, I consider it a great movie.

" @Twilight said:

" ... I thought that many of the jokes were like something I'd find in Dreamworks movie. "

That's a pretty vicious insult. "