So I've seen some sources praising this game's backstory, but...

  • 79 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for hailinel
#1 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -

Now, I haven't played Homefront, so maybe there's something I'm missing in the context, but from the sidelines, I'm having a very difficult time understanding how some are praising the game's backstory.  In order for the game's plot to be even remotely plausible, it requires a chain of events that's too implausible to be believable and seems more apt to rely on shocking imagery, like soldiers gunning down a mother in front of a small child, than actually explaining a plausible invasion scenario.
 
From the Giant Bomb wiki:
 

Timeline 

  • 2011: "North Korea's weapons program continues to intensify .... has surpassed 1000 missiles" This shows that North Korea is arming itself. Some countries also want the UN to put severe sanctions against North Korea.
 
Okay, fine.  The U.N. has proven time and again that they're incredibly slow to react when it comes to such situations.

  • 2012: "This morning comes the news of Kim Jong Il's death" Kim Jong has died. "North Korea greets there new leader son of Kim Jong Ils son Kim Jong-un"
 
This is perfectly plausible as well.  Kim Jon Il is not a young man, and he hasn't seemed particularly healthy in recent years.

  • 2013: "Kim Jong-un has united north and south Korea" This now forms the Greater Korean Republic.
 
Okay, what.  North Korea takes over South Korea in a single year without any apparent resistance or outside intervention.

  • 2015: "Costs at the pump are ready to break the $20 price" This forces America to become destabilized.
 
Or maybe invest in electric cars.

  • 2017: "Civil unrest has intensified with the demise of the US dollar" There are a lot of riots in America and the military has started to pull out of Asia and other countries.
 
And the cause of the U.S. dollar's demise is...?

  • 2018: "Under threat of annihilation by the Greater Korean Republic....Japan has surrendered" Japan now joins the Greater Korean Republic. Riots continue during 2018-2022.
 
So Korea takes over Japan, and once again, the international community apparently doesn't give a shit.

  • 2022: "The president ordered a freeze on bank withdraws." The US economy has completely failed.
 
Wow, they're really playing the worst case scenario card here.  Everybody panic!

  • 2024: "Korean annexation continues to spread" Korea takes over many Asian countries such as the Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, and Myanmar.
 
You'd think that someone would have thought to maybe fight back by now.  It didn't even take the invasion of this many countries to trigger World War II.

  • 2025: "The Greater Korean Republic has launched its latest communication satellite claiming it will bring a message of peace" This satellite is really a EMP that knocks out near all electronics in America. The Greater Korean Republic begin the invasion. Greater Korean Republic takes over Hawaii and San Francisco.
 
Magic science technology thing cripples all of America in one fell swoop.  How incredibly realistic.

  • 2026: "US military scattered" This is due to communications being down and the surprise of the attack.
 
You'd think that given the shenanigans that Korea had been up to for over a decade, the U.S. would have been better prepared for a Korean invasion by this point.
 
I mean, seriously.  What.  In some ways, this is even more ridiculous than Red Dawn.
Avatar image for punk1984
#2 Posted by Punk1984 (595 posts) -
@Hailinel: how dare you besmirch the memory of the Swayze by linking him with this cheap knock off of a knock off...I say 'Good Day Sir.'
 
No but you're totally right
Avatar image for the_laughing_man
#3 Posted by The_Laughing_Man (13807 posts) -

Wont the back story be less impact full for people who are playing the game Outside of the U.S? I mean why would someone in the U.k be like" This could happen" When they see a hooters with Koreans in it....does the U.K even know what Hooters is? 

Avatar image for blueaniman93
#4 Posted by blueaniman93 (620 posts) -

Yeah I know.

I've heard people talking about this being realistic, and it's kind of ridiculous.

IGN did an article on it. If you really want to get pissed off, 

  
Avatar image for make_me_mad
#5 Posted by Make_Me_Mad (3227 posts) -

What they mean by "Great Premise" is that everyone who grew up in the 80s has been waiting for a Red Dawn videogame ever since.

Avatar image for dantheman1515
#6 Posted by dantheman1515 (318 posts) -

Ya its really dumb. I doubt North Korea will still exist in 2026. There bound to fuck up some time in the next 16 years and then will be subsequently wiped clean. If Koreans were muslim then America would've already invaded, but our government is still worried about fighting its holy war against the middle east.

Avatar image for punk1984
#7 Posted by Punk1984 (595 posts) -

Product placement does nothing for immersion...
When I was ducking behind the full throttle energy drink machine, I wasn't thinking "Man this is just like real life."  I was thinking, "Why the hell is this gas station totally trashed and yet these two pop machines are totally okay even though they obviously been knocked over and pushed across the floor? And for that matter do they even make these machines in real life? I mean those Full throttle cans are tall boys. Does that work in one of these machines or does it need to be one of those robot arm ones. Oh I'm getting shot through the cover - thanks for nothing Full Throttle next time I'm getting a Red Bull."
 
I can't wait until I see the Tiger Direct.com store that doesn't exist in real life.

Avatar image for lordandrew
#8 Posted by LordAndrew (14601 posts) -
@Hailinel said:
"
  • 2025: "The Greater Korean Republic has launched its latest communication satellite claiming it will bring a message of peace" This satellite is really a EMP that knocks out near all electronics in America. The Greater Korean Republic begin the invasion. Greater Korean Republic takes over Hawaii and San Francisco.
 
Magic science technology thing cripples all of America in one fell swoop.  How incredibly realistic.
"
Damn PSE law!
Avatar image for handsomedead
#9 Posted by HandsomeDead (11853 posts) -

Breaking News: Hailinel doesn't like a western game. Latest Developments: Picks holes in fictional storyline; Thinks he's actually making a point.

Avatar image for mooseymcman
#10 Posted by MooseyMcMan (12541 posts) -

North Korea can barely keep itself afloat, let alone conquer S. Korea, Japan, etc. And there really is no way the international community would sit by and let this happen. I mean, they're stepping in to help out Libya (or attack it, kinda both). 

Avatar image for handsomedead
#11 Posted by HandsomeDead (11853 posts) -
@MooseyMcMan said:
" North Korea can barely keep itself afloat, let alone conquer S. Korea, Japan, etc. And there really is no way the international community would sit by and let this happen. I mean, they're stepping in to help out Libya (or attack it, kinda both).  "
You're right. This game isn't a documentary at all.
Avatar image for hailinel
#12 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -
@HandsomeDead said:
" Breaking News: Hailinel doesn't like a western game. Latest Developments: Picks holes in fictional storyline; Thinks he's actually making a point. "
And your point would be?
 
Oh, right.  You don't have one.
 
@Punk1984 said:
"I can't wait until I see the Tiger Direct.com store that doesn't exist in real life. "

Just wait until 2026, when Tiger Direct.com has retail locations across America and yet still includes the .com on its retail location signage.
Avatar image for dany
#13 Posted by Dany (8018 posts) -

The leap from N. Korea and S. Korea reuniting is not going to happen in our lifetime let alone in 3 years. But again, fiction, once it makes that leap, it can make any fate future broadcast plausible right?

Avatar image for mracoon
#14 Posted by mracoon (5099 posts) -
@HandsomeDead:@Hailinel: Guys, stop. If you want to continue your little argument then do it in PMs and leave it off the forums.
Moderator
Avatar image for fluxwavez
#15 Posted by FluxWaveZ (19836 posts) -

Oh come on. Most have been saying that the game's backstory is crap. What are these "some sources" you're referring to?

Avatar image for enigma777
#16 Posted by Enigma777 (6285 posts) -
@Hailinel: Praising the backstory doesn't mean it has to be plausible, just that it's good....
Avatar image for 1337w422102
#17 Edited by 1337W422102 (1204 posts) -

Canadian here.  I saw the trailer for the the game and have no interest in it whatsoever.  My reaction to the trailer is pretty much what the OP describes.  Sounds like more LOL FREEDUM AND LIBERTEEEEEE fearmongering.  But I can't help but get flashbacks of oldschool games in a similar vein, like Rush'n Attack.

Avatar image for bloodgraiv3
#18 Posted by Bloodgraiv3 (2730 posts) -
@MooseyMcMan said:
"North Korea can barely keep itself afloat, let alone conquer S. Korea, Japan, etc. And there really is no way the international community would sit by and let this happen. I mean, they're stepping in to help out Libya (or attack it, kinda both).  "

Pretty much this. 
Avatar image for hailinel
#19 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -
@FluxWaveZ said:
" Oh come on. Most have been saying that the game's backstory is crap. What are these "some sources" you're referring to? "
The GameTrailers narrator made me raise my eyebrow a few times, as have other scattered online comments.  I'm not saying that there's this great wave of people proclaiming this profound belief in the game's plausibility, but they're out there.  And apparently ignorant toward the current geopolitical and military climate surrounding the Korean peninsula.
Avatar image for arbitrarywater
#20 Posted by ArbitraryWater (14686 posts) -

Who are these people who are saying these things? Sure, it's a ludicrous enough setup for a Red Dawn wannabe like Homefront, but that doesn't make it good or plausible.

Avatar image for bravetoaster
#21 Posted by BraveToaster (12636 posts) -

Not only would it take longer than a year to unite, it would take years for them to recover from all that fighting. 

Avatar image for captaincody
#22 Posted by CaptainCody (1551 posts) -
@HandsomeDead said:
"Breaking News: Hailinel doesn't like a western game. Latest Developments: Picks holes in fictional storyline; Thinks he's actually making a point. "

I love you.
Avatar image for relentlessknight
#23 Posted by RelentlessKnight (1132 posts) -

it's just a "what-if" scenario, I don't believe it should be taken seriously

Avatar image for czarpyotr
#24 Posted by Czarpyotr (409 posts) -

and the stocks fall even LOWER!!!

Avatar image for endaround
#25 Posted by endaround (2267 posts) -

Best part is how $20 a gallon oil cripples the US but doesn't affect North Korea.  This must have found a source of unobtanium.  Or maybe their navy is all sail powered?

Avatar image for lordandrew
#26 Posted by LordAndrew (14601 posts) -
@CaptainCody: Knock it off.
Avatar image for ajayraz
#27 Posted by AjayRaz (12803 posts) -

there should be a video game where the actual territory of countries fight against each other. i'm not talking about the US army or some shit but all of the land that makes up the USA fighting against all of the land that makes up North Korea. that would be ballin' 

Avatar image for hailinel
#28 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" there should be a video game where the actual territory of countries fight against each other. i'm not talking about the US army or some shit but all of the land that makes up the USA fighting against all of the land that makes up North Korea. that would be ballin'  "
That would be psychedelic.
 
@endaround said:
" Best part is how $20 a gallon oil cripples the US but doesn't affect North Korea.  This must have found a source of unobtanium.  Or maybe their navy is all sail powered? "
Or the entire Korean peninsula must have struck oil around 2014.
Avatar image for ajayraz
#29 Posted by AjayRaz (12803 posts) -
@Hailinel: but it would be pretty sweet. c'mon, you have to admit it. 
Avatar image for kingzetta
#30 Posted by kingzetta (4497 posts) -

Backstory? you mean the movie Red Dawn?

Avatar image for animasta
#31 Posted by Animasta (14903 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @Hailinel: but it would be pretty sweet. c'mon, you have to admit it.  "
would it be like the portrait fights in dragonball evolution?
Avatar image for ajayraz
#32 Posted by AjayRaz (12803 posts) -
@Laketown said:
" @AjayRaz said:
" @Hailinel: but it would be pretty sweet. c'mon, you have to admit it.  "
would it be like the portrait fights in dragonball evolution? "
pretty much, except you have countries body slamming each other 
Avatar image for thedj93
#33 Posted by thedj93 (1260 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @Hailinel: but it would be pretty sweet. c'mon, you have to admit it.  "
shit, just make america have the personality, fashion sense, and vocabulary of a grizzled space-marine, and I'm SOLD
Avatar image for ajayraz
#34 Posted by AjayRaz (12803 posts) -
@thedj93 said:
" @AjayRaz said:
" @Hailinel: but it would be pretty sweet. c'mon, you have to admit it.  "
shit, just make america have the personality, fashion sense, and vocabulary of a grizzled space-marine, and I'm SOLD "
way ahead of you brah 
Avatar image for genkkaku
#35 Posted by Genkkaku (759 posts) -

Not even one mention of Australia.. 
 
In this timeline were either to lazy or to drunk to care i guess

Avatar image for animasta
#36 Posted by Animasta (14903 posts) -
@Genkkaku said:
" Not even one mention of Australia..  In this timeline were either to lazy or to drunk to care i guess "
the GKR or whatever actually took over Australia and now use it as their prison colony.
 
ironic huh
Avatar image for hailinel
#37 Posted by Hailinel (25787 posts) -
@AjayRaz said:
" @Hailinel: but it would be pretty sweet. c'mon, you have to admit it.  "
I'd play it.  I admit it.
Avatar image for make_me_mad
#38 Posted by Make_Me_Mad (3227 posts) -

I think it would be better if they handled their history the way Vanquish did - forget trying to make your ridiculous setup seem realistic or plausible and just throw things at you.  The attempts to make the events seem like even a remote possibility make it that much more ridiculous.

Also, Giant Bomb threads have been degenerating into insult flinging for no reason entirely too often lately.  Stop it.

Avatar image for punk1984
#39 Posted by Punk1984 (595 posts) -
@Genkkaku said:
" Not even one mention of Australia..  In this timeline were either to lazy or to drunk to care i guess "
So par for the course then?
Avatar image for handsomedead
#40 Posted by HandsomeDead (11853 posts) -
@Make_Me_Mad said:
" I think it would be better if they handled their history the way Vanquish did - forget trying to make your ridiculous setup seem realistic or plausible and just throw things at you.  The attempts to make the events seem like even a remote possibility make it that much more ridiculous. "
So the best course of action is to not even try?
Avatar image for icysandman
#41 Posted by IcySandman (481 posts) -

Damn people are just taking shots at Homefront, I suppose 3 stars is the killing fields.

Avatar image for make_me_mad
#42 Posted by Make_Me_Mad (3227 posts) -
@HandsomeDead said:
" @Make_Me_Mad said:
" I think it would be better if they handled their history the way Vanquish did - forget trying to make your ridiculous setup seem realistic or plausible and just throw things at you.  The attempts to make the events seem like even a remote possibility make it that much more ridiculous. "
So the best course of action is to not even try? "
I think when your premise is so ridiculous to start with, you need to embrace that absurdity whole hog to keep it from being incredibly awkward.  Trying to ground it like they did just highlights all the places that the fiction breaks.
Avatar image for n7
#43 Posted by N7 (4159 posts) -

It seems really hard to fuck up the whole "OMG America got invaded! OMG!" story. I mean, Red Dawn did it pretty nicely because it didn't really go into a deep discussion about it. Shit happened, and shit continued to happen. That's about as far as they went.
 
Homefront had a lot of awesome possibilities. I knew that it was going to be terrible around the time that one interview came out and the guy said something like they were putting most of the effort into the multiplayer side of things.
 
I guess we'll have to wait another, what, 30 years for a real Red Dawn video game?

Avatar image for shivermetimbers
#44 Posted by shivermetimbers (1334 posts) -

Very little alternate history fiction makes any sense, it's just for fun. It's just Homefront was being a little pretentious about it because it's the first game to describe it at great length. 

Avatar image for dalai
#45 Posted by Dalai (7868 posts) -

I guess we'll all find out in 15 years if this is all even possible.

Avatar image for punk1984
#46 Posted by Punk1984 (595 posts) -
@IcySandman said:
" Damn people are just taking shots at Homefront, I suppose 3 stars is the killing fields. "
Actually according to Homefront those are in the infield of a little league baseball diamond
Avatar image for apathylad
#47 Posted by Apathylad (3234 posts) -

Is leaving the body of a dead American in a Russian airport with the goal of starting a Russian invasion plausible? You'd think the place would have some security cameras. 

Avatar image for dystopiax
#48 Edited by DystopiaX (5661 posts) -
@Apathylad said:

" Is leaving the body of a dead American in a Russian airport with the goal of starting a Russian invasion plausible? You'd think the place would have some security cameras.  "

The difference is that MW2, while using a modern setting, is not using the same kind of "YO THIS SHIT COULD HAPPEN" marketing that Homefront has. It would be one thing to say "lol we came up with this story with this unique situation" and another to say "YO play this game it'll be just like the future" 
Also, they claim the story is good on a logical standpoint. MW2 doesn't, they just say "YO YOU GET TO BLOW SHIT UP"! Which is fine by me.
@shivermetimbers said:

" Very little alternate history fiction makes any sense, it's just for fun. It's just Homefront was being a little pretentious about it because it's the first game to describe it at great length.  "

Some are more plausible than others. For example, one I just read had the Union losing at Gettysberg because Lee's orders were never found- plausible, because the union's victory hinged on them knowing what the Confederate armies are going to do. If they lose there, and lose everything (again, plausible) no army of the potomac=Union defeat of the civil war. Hell of a lot more plausible than NK randomly beating SK in a year, before the US is destabilized, without China doing anything. Keep in mind that when NK fired on SK this year, China came out and said it would not support NK if they exhibited further aggression. That, and Hailinel's point- that $20 per gallon would likely force alternative fuel sources for cars- is perfectly legitimate. On top of that, why the hell won't anyone else defend Japan? A big part of the story is dependant on the fact that the people allied against NK won't help each other, and current events shows that this isn't true.
Avatar image for vinny_says
#49 Posted by Vinny_Says (5914 posts) -

Hey man video games!! Fuck it how do you know Mass Effect won't happen in the future?

Avatar image for peasantabuse
#50 Posted by PeasantAbuse (5098 posts) -

 
Actually, I just looked outside and this is all totally happening in front of my house.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.