There is also a case to be said for the idea that they were indeed twins at one point in time, but Hannah had actually killed Eve as a child and went on to develop a split personality to "keep Eve alive" within her, in a sense. The fact that 'Eve' sings "Oh The Wind & Rain", with the content of the lyrics of that song being two people falling in love with the same man and one of them being killed by the other surely can't be a coincidence (wait, can it?!).
Overall, it definitely seems like there is no one definitive story that is made apparent to the player, which is precisely the point of the game - it's deliberately ambiguous in order for people to come to their own conclusions. There seems to be evidence pointing to the 'twins' story, the 'split personality' story and maybe even a mixture of the two.
Honestly, I came off the story pretty damn sure that they were actual twins (given the speeding tickets, hospital records and other evidence), but the more I read about it the more complex everything gets and now I don't even know what to think. But goddamn, I loved the experience. It's truly masterful storytelling, in my opinion.
Log in to comment