I believe this goes down in the "Jeff hates Red Dead Redemption" level of how poorly an argument was made for a game.
Some caveats up front:
I never do this, ever. The arguments were so infuriating that I had to say something.
Picking apart an argument made in person is not fair when I have had some time to digest the arguments.
I enjoyed Destiny for what it was, a very flawed game.
Now in no particular order:
Diablo 3 absolutely has hand crafted items with flavour text; and they have more impact on how a class plays. They can modify abilities, proc effects and can be items which people make builds around.
Diablo 3 again, the maps are randomly generated including random Elite and Champion encounters with their own resistances. Like the elites in Destiny but with more unique abilities and more resistances.
I only mention Diablo 3 because he made an equivocation himself, which rings so false having played a stupid amount of both games they are barely similar outside having loot.
Nightfall and Raids cannot be match made. This is inconceivable. The argument that its too hardcore for a pickup group is ridiculous and fundamentally proven wrong by the DestinyLFG third party site. I cannot access the "best content in the game", the game WILL NOT LET ME. I could randomly friend people in game and try to group with them, but what the fuck difference is that than just hitting a matchmaking button? I can do it with everything else, including PVP. It is the absolute worst aspect of destiny.
Grinding and attunement was weeded out of MMOs 5 years ago for a reason. It isn't fun, its a meaningless timesink and 100% of the time is looked back on as a mistake.
The whole engram system is idiotic. Its like having an identify scroll but with a decent chance of getting something worse than you anticipated.
Going back to the tower is dumb. Every godamn time you have to load in and talk to some faceless NPC. The tower is a meaningless hub, there are no social features whatsoever, its the mass effect elevators all over again.
The mission design is pathetic. You defend that boring ass robot so many times I felt sad by the end of it.
This thread will probably be a horrible mess of people hating on Brad, which I am sorry for because I don't want it to be that at all.
Opinions are subjective and all are valid, but some of the facts glossed over or misrepresented were terrible.
Log in to comment