GOTY 2011
NOTE: I dug up an old external hard drive that had a bunch of old reviews and stuff from like 2007-2012. This GOTY list was among the documents I found. There were no modifications to the list, but in retrospect, I would absolutely update with some other games. There was even a footnote regarding some games missing on the list.
(Games I wish I had played or had more time to play so that I could have potentially included them on the list: The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Saint’s Row: The Third, Rayman: Origins, Dark Souls, AKB 1/48: Idol to Guam de Koi Shitara)