Ok, I just finished the game last week cause work got in the way. And well, Skyward Sword is still a compelling game on the Wii, I just cant see it being touted as the best Zelda game now that I finished it. It is true that the controls, although fiddly at times though minimal, was a breathe of fresh air from all the button oriented games I've played (which is the majority, unless you count Wii Sports and Resorts). The sword swinging made me remember all those day dreams back then of me going on an adventure, swinging my sword against bad guys and using my shield to protect people.
But enough of day dreams, on the game! The controls were great, the story was awesome! (great origins story for the Master Sword), but in terms of the scope in gameplay; not so much. Sure the fights were awesome due to the controls, but in terms of what I was expecting whenever I traversed thru an area or a temple; it just didn't cut it for me. I never got a head scratch on thinking on the puzzles, nor a face palm on the sheer obvious "Its right in front of me! Doh!" moments I had before when I was playing other Zelda games. And that was something I missed, other than the controls, the game did not surprise me! In every dungeon I knew what needed to be done or had an idea what needed to be done, and that was something I never experienced when playing other Zelda games.
Its that sheer puzzlement whenever you're in a dungeon that really captivated me with the franchise, and although I'm not tired of the familiar formula, not finding that feeling in the game just left me a bit boggled. Maybe I was wrong in expecting the game to reach high marks on everything, but I guess that was what I wanted to get from the game. Not from all the hype, but because its a new Zelda game.
Skyward Sword is still a great game though, but its such a shame that Nintendo never felt like doing something new (other than the controls!) with the franchise, gameplay wise. I mean maybe adding some side quests with variety or puzzles that are really really puzzling; i dunno. But for now, I'm just going to start playing Minish Cap again.
Log in to comment