Is Handibot a Human or a Robot?

Avatar image for snail
Posted by Snail (8904 posts) 1 year, 8 months ago

Poll: Is Handibot a Human or a Robot? (916 votes)

Human 90%
Robot 10%

I was personally convinced that it was a robot programmed with some funny lines, but then I started thinking about how when he was paintballing, he was not in the rec room. If Handibot was just, well, a bot, and not a dude with a microphone, he would probably be present in every section of the game to "help" people out.

Also the supposed voice recognition worked in the favor of comedy too often. And he played paintball pretty well. That was some proper paintball AI for a developer making a game for free.

I don't know what to believe in anymore???? Help me Giant Bomb!

Avatar image for jennifyre
#2 Posted by Jennifyre (481 posts) -

Lets not leave out the totally uncool things he said too such as "Can I help you with your diapers?", "Grow a pair." Singing some strange song about how he can touch you ahywhere during the paintball match. Asking Jeff at one point if he needed help looking less "gay".

Pretty obviously a real person trolling. It's just novel because it's over voice chat rather than text. Weird stuff like that happens often in MMO type games. Probably just a lonely person who has trouble interacting with others normally so is getting attention in another way.

Avatar image for twolines
#3 Edited by TwoLines (3633 posts) -

Absolutely positive that it was just a weird guy pretending to be a robot.

Avatar image for wynnduffy
#4 Edited by WynnDuffy (1289 posts) -

@jennifyre said:

Lets not leave out the totally uncool things he said too such as "Can I help you with your diapers?", "Grow a pair." Singing some strange song about how he can touch you ahywhere during the paintball match. Asking Jeff at one point if he needed help looking less "gay".

Pretty obviously a real person trolling. It's just novel because it's over voice chat rather than text. Weird stuff like that happens often in MMO type games. Probably just a lonely person who has trouble interacting with others normally so is getting attention in another way.

Someone joking around on voice chat means they are likely a lonely person with social problems?

Wow...

Your examples are not standing out to me as "totally uncool". A little crass but he didn't say anything that needs to be called out.

Hats off to Handibot's human for providing a strange, funny experience for other players, the perfect character for Rec Room and floaty VR hands.

Avatar image for spedstyle
#5 Posted by Spedstyle (28 posts) -

i just assumed right away it was someone doing a Mr Meeseeks (from rick and morty) impression

Avatar image for naoiko
#6 Posted by Naoiko (1625 posts) -

I'd going to vote and say both. Maybe while the dudes off line it is a robot, and it can be player controlled when he's online.

Avatar image for razzuel
#7 Posted by razzuel (399 posts) -

Assuredly human. I do appreciate his commitment to the bit. It made the Rec Room portion of the VRodeo pretty hilarious.

@jasoncooke: No, some of the things Handibot said are definitely uncool. Maybe they didn't make you upset, but some of what he said would certainly make other people uncomfortable and unwelcome. Also, as a lonely person with social issues, I think @jennifyre's assessment feels pretty accurate.

Avatar image for camwil
#8 Edited by camwil (77 posts) -
Avatar image for dudeglove
#9 Edited by dudeglove (13318 posts) -

Rec Room is the VR evolution of Velvet Sundown, meaning that I really want Vinny to play Rec Room.

And yes, Handibot was a real person.

Avatar image for wynnduffy
#10 Edited by WynnDuffy (1289 posts) -
@razzuel said:

@jasoncooke: No, some of the things Handibot said are definitely uncool. Maybe they didn't make you upset, but some of what he said would certainly make other people uncomfortable and unwelcome. Also, as a lonely person with social issues, I think @jennifyre's assessment feels pretty accurate.

I think it's reaching to say he has social issues for pretending to be a bot for the sake of comedy.

If a woman or a kid becomes offended by "Grow a pair" or "Help with your diapers" then the Internet is going to be rough...

Avatar image for dinosaurcanada
#11 Posted by DinosaurCanada (892 posts) -

He is my soul

Avatar image for dgtlty
#12 Posted by dgtlty (1001 posts) -
Avatar image for selbie
#13 Posted by selbie (2511 posts) -
Avatar image for thekramer89
#14 Posted by TheKramer89 (544 posts) -

Is handibot frog fractions 2?

Avatar image for drflapjack
#15 Posted by DrFlapjack (362 posts) -

@razzuel@jennifyre@jasoncooke Don't worry about it, people get way too easily offended theses days. I just nod my head and walk away. I was having a conversation the other day and said the word "triggered" and the other person responded "You shouldn't say that word, it could offend people that have issues with things that set them off." At this point having any type of different opinion is causing an issue, but hey, welcome to the internet. I enjoy people like Handibot that try to lighten it up a bit.

Avatar image for dukemcfrenzy
#16 Posted by DukeMcFrenzy (129 posts) -

@drflapjack: that person you had a conversation with got triggered by the word triggered?

Avatar image for johnymyko
#17 Edited by JohnyMyko (1588 posts) -

From the breath on the mic, the misreading of nicknames, the changes of tone on the voice, the bad singing and the random jokes he tried to say, it's more than obvious that it is a real guy trying to be funny. And failing miserably so, being more cringe-worthy than anything. Let's be honest, the only funny thing about Handibot was the way Jeff interacted with him.

It's the new internet, everyone gets offended by everything now. I probably offended someone just by typing this.

Avatar image for ghost_cat
#18 Posted by ghost_cat (2104 posts) -

You can hear him stumbling and changing his pitch from time to time. It lame yet novel for a bit, but then it just got sad, and I just wanted to reach out to tell him "It's okay."

Avatar image for mellotronrules
#19 Posted by mellotronrules (2341 posts) -

he's clearly an internet person.

Avatar image for jesus_phish
#20 Posted by Jesus_Phish (3592 posts) -

It's a dude. Whatever about him saying something that people view as offensive, but people ragging on him for doing something goofy, enjoying himself is just kind of dumb.

Stuff like this guy can make things like MMOs and online social hubs really fun. And for most of the stream he genuinely seemed to be useful. When Jeff asked about punching something with his fists, the dude told him there was a punching doll located behind him, which there was. He could also tell people what menus to go through, so either he's put some effort into this or he works for/with the development team.

I can't remember when he said "gay" but it seemed to be when some other player came on and started talking shit to him and trying to get something out of him. The dude who said "nothing but net" - when there was no net - if I remember right.

Avatar image for johnymyko
#21 Posted by JohnyMyko (1588 posts) -

@jesus_phish: The "gay" part was when Jeff said he could go back the the room to change clothes and Handibot said something like "maybe you could look less gay".

Avatar image for ripelivejam
#22 Posted by ripelivejam (12593 posts) -

are we human or are we handibot?

Avatar image for mrcraggle
#23 Posted by mrcraggle (3050 posts) -

There was another VR social thing the GB crew tried out (can't remember what it was called) but one of the devs was talking to people as they came in and tried to help them so at first I thought Handibot was something similar but it just turned out to be a dude doing a bit.

Avatar image for wynnduffy
#24 Edited by WynnDuffy (1289 posts) -

1:15:40 on the Rec Room video: https://youtu.be/STeglH9T7nA?t=4540

Handibot listening in and responding to their conversation and Dan's look to Brad, combined with the perfectly timed music was a great moment haha.

Avatar image for physicalscience
#25 Posted by physicalscience (306 posts) -

I thought he was funny.

VR is weird.

Avatar image for seakae
#26 Posted by seakae (260 posts) -

Handibot is a robot.

His name isn't HandiMAN, duh.

Avatar image for wulfbane
#27 Edited by WulfBane (259 posts) -
Avatar image for ezdude
#28 Posted by ezdude (450 posts) -

MonsterDrunk.

Avatar image for colossalghost
#29 Edited by ColossalGhost (240 posts) -

The first time Handibot said MonsterDunk, the second time they said MonsterDrunk. I also don't believe for a second that the developers would program a helper bot to make those kind of slightly to off-color jokes.

Avatar image for shindig
#30 Posted by Shindig (4623 posts) -

Never estimate the colour of a developer's humour.

Avatar image for meptron
#31 Posted by Meptron (1311 posts) -

YouTube channel is part of an elaborate ruse that allows this robot to pass the Turing test.

Avatar image for beachthunder
#32 Posted by BeachThunder (14998 posts) -

In a way, aren't we all robots?

Avatar image for georgie85
#33 Posted by Georgie85 (8 posts) -
No Caption Provided

Avatar image for clagnaught
#34 Posted by clagnaught (1910 posts) -

Either. Or both.

Avatar image for wynnduffy
#35 Posted by WynnDuffy (1289 posts) -

Handibot is funded by Palmer Luckey

Avatar image for songhunter
#36 Posted by Songhunter (42 posts) -

If I was an emergent IA, what better way to pass of as a human and study the behavior of the newer generations than though an online avatar and a youtube channel?

Hatsune Miku is coming for all of your asses!

Avatar image for bluemorning104
#37 Posted by bluemorning104 (20 posts) -
Avatar image for audiobusting
#38 Posted by audioBusting (2553 posts) -

This is going to end in Handibot being tasked to hunt down and destroy rogue androids and discovering a terrible secret about himself.

Avatar image for crocbox
#39 Edited by CrocBox (514 posts) -

A human robot.

@meptron said:

YouTube channel is part of an elaborate ruse that allows this robot to pass the Turing test.

So basically the robot version of Poppy.

Avatar image for selbie
#40 Edited by selbie (2511 posts) -

Handibot strikes again...

Loading Video...

Avatar image for doctordonkey
#41 Edited by doctordonkey (1610 posts) -

@selbie: That is equal parts hilarious and disconcertingly terrifying.

Avatar image for dgtlty
#42 Posted by dgtlty (1001 posts) -

Strong contender for Best New Character.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.