Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb Review

107 Comments

Aliens vs. Predator Review

2
  • X360

While there's still a certain charm to its interspecies play, AVP is plagued with issues across the board.


   Marine shoots Alien, Alien eats Marine, Predator stands back and laughs about it.
  Marine shoots Alien, Alien eats Marine, Predator stands back and laughs about it.
There's something conceptually terrific about the three-way dance that is Aliens vs. Predator, but Rebellion's rework of the formula--which has been around for well over 15 years now--flubs the execution in a lot of different ways. The franchise's class-based take on multiplayer combat still elicits a few thrilling moments, but the three single-player campaigns aren't any fun at all.

Aliens vs. Predator is all about the differences between the three playable factions. The Marines carry weapons, like the iconic Aliens pulse rifle and even more iconic Aliens motion detector, which blips out frequently enough to let you know that something's moving out there, but not often enough to serve as a direct map to your enemies. The aliens are a purely melee class that can crawl on walls, see well in the dark, and detect silhouettes of enemies through solid surfaces. Predators can cloak themselves, get two vision modes to help them see the other races, and are largely a melee class as well. But they can collect and use specific Predator weapons as they hunt. These weapons end up being especially devastating, but they're kept in check by low fire-rates and a finite amount of energy for your beam weapons.

  A big part of the Alien campaign involves putting Facehuggers onto faces.
  A big part of the Alien campaign involves putting Facehuggers onto faces.
So with two classes relying heavily on strikes, that melee combat needs to be pretty good for the game to work. But it doesn't fit with the action especially well, and the end result is a rock-paper-scissors-like system of strikes, blocking, and counters that feels out-of-place in the game's fiction and also isn't much fun to perform. The aliens end up feeling especially weak. These things are bred to rip out the throats of the opposition and claw them apart in the process. Standing still, holding down the block controls and waiting for your enemy to strike so you can counter just feels silly. These mechanics do, however, make AVP feel very different than your average first-person shooter, which is a nice reprieve from the standard rifle/shotgun/sniper/rockets gameplay that you've come to expect from the typical sci-fi first-person shooter. The game offers a variety of different multiplayer modes, too, but on the 360 version, it was often hard to find players. You may have to wait around for five or 10 minutes before collecting enough players to get a game started.

Of course, that doesn't forgive the game's single-player portion, which drags you through the same dull events from three different perspectives. At best, the instruction you get on the use of your class's tools makes it a passable tutorial for the multiplayer. At its worst, though, AVP contains multiple scripting bugs where things that were supposed to happen simply didn't, forcing me to restart at the most recent checkpoint and hope that the game would carry forward. Also, the AI can't pilot an alien very well at all, like it can't deal with the concept of running up walls. If there's a pillar between you and an alien, it'll run up the side of it and start twitching and spinning around. It gets its bearings after a few seconds, but it looks pretty terrible. It'll take around six or seven hours to work through all three campaigns on the default difficulty setting, but they're not really worth seeing through to their conclusions.

That's really the largest problem with Aliens vs. Predator. There's no one solid aspect of it to make up for the other, busted-up parts. You're left with the impression that the single-player was an afterthought and that multiplayer was the focus. But even the multiplayer is saddled with enough flaws to make this game missable.
Jeff Gerstmann on Google+

107 Comments

Avatar image for lspear76
lspear76

22

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By lspear76
@ShadowDoGG: Well, I only played the Predator campaign and the first few missions of the Marine campaign, and enjoyed it. I've taken a break from the game and have been playing other games recently. But, I really did like the Predator campaign... I honestly can't tell the difference as to why a game like Halo is considered great and why AvP would be considered bad. I wouldn't buy a game like Call of Duty Modern Warfare, either. To me, all those games are overrated. I'd rather playing games like AvP, for the Xbox 360, or even the Jaguar version. 
Avatar image for hotsocks
hotsocks

2

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By hotsocks

Not surprised at the short review for. Shallow Shallow game IMO.  As a game not much to talk about.
 
@Ispear76 (You should have a tag behind  your name that says "I think I'm cool because I play games with low scores", wait that's too long but anyway)
 
Fun is a subjective term. Everyone doesn't think watching sports is "fun", but I do and that's all that matters. Hey, someone could think your shirts purple when you thinks it's blue. Come one though, Jeff REVIEWS games. This game has  flaws that actually effect the fun for SOME people. That doesn't mean that you can't have fun with it. Also, Jeff wouldn't be doing his job as game game CRITIC if he overlooked flaws for the "fun".
 
I played the heck out of Lord of the Rings: Conquest online, but I didn't complain about bad reviews. I was having fun. I also realized that it did have flaws. Take those rose colored glasses off. 
 
And yes IGN (7/10 from them), Gamespot, and Giantbomb (4/10 from them) all review games, good for you that you noticed.

Avatar image for treppass
Treppass

126

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Treppass

well i dont think this game deserved a score as low as 2
yes it could have done more but in thoroughly enjoying the game multiplayer
there it nothing that feel quite like running rings round a marine then sticking you tail in his face

Avatar image for nemesis
Nemesis

330

Forum Posts

569

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 1

Edited By Nemesis

Nice to see you didn't review this game with beer-goggles or to please the idiotic AvP fanboys. This game is such garbage, but it is somehow tolerated by the fanboys.

Avatar image for lambert
Lambert

405

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Lambert

I'm glad I rented this first. I was really hoping for a great, next-gen AvP game.

Avatar image for vackillers
VACkillers

1286

Forum Posts

82

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 4

Edited By VACkillers

ok well i may get flammed but thats ok wouldn't be the first time lol but this game surely deserves a higher score then TWO!!! wtf? at its worst its a 3 star game, but a lot of jeff was mentioning in the game i've not had a problem with, for example the AI controlling aliens, if theres a pillar between you and the alien  it simply tries to run up it? LMAO that would be funny as hell if i saw that, in my 15 hour experience with the PC! version, i've never experienced this, not a single time! they get that close they usually rip me in half !! This is the problem when you have multi-platform games that originally were made for one platform only.... 
 
I thought the storys were actually very good, like how you star each race as the alien marine or predator, was very well done, was really awesome escaping that room at the start of the alien campaine how can you not like that stuff? and the graphics are absolutely amazing!!  
 
When you play as the marine, i found it to be scary as hell running through those corridors not knowing what the fuck is around the next corner! dind't anyone like that? like at all ?? I think far too many ppl sucked in by some REALLY mediocre games like borderlands and halo 2 and 3 which games like this, get compared to.
 
The only thing that i really do agree with jeff on this one, is the melee combat really is poor, the original was definitely far better at dealing with one shot kills or 1 blow kills all gameplay, this shoulda been looked into a bit more as there is a lot you could have done with the close quaters but feels some what of a hatch job just to add it in there because they can. When you do actually play as the alien, you really do die a bit too quick and i noticed that on the multiplayer demo on steam before the release.
 
I am an AvsP fan boy, but i was skeptical about the game before i played it, and im damn glad i got it, its got poor reviews all over the web. and i think most of it is totally un just. If ppl are more willing to fork out 60 bucks on a halo or crysis copy, go right ahead, you wont find anything that plays quite like this...
 
and my suggestion to ppl that haven't played it yet and are looking at these reviews and get turned away, give it a try first !!!  and use a pc....

Avatar image for space_coyote
space_coyote

6

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

I'm playing through it right now. It's not bad per se...just not very interesting