What did you think of the good ending of the Journey? Did you like it? What was your interpretation of it? 
 
For me it just sucked, compared to the rest of the game. The main character is supposed to die, so what are those final three days (including graduation day)? A dream, or did he suffer from a degenerative disease that killed him after a month? No explanation is given for it.  
 
It feels so disconnected... Well, that's what we get for a philosophical ending. 

I assume you mean the pre FES ending (I think?). I actually liked it for reasons I just almost spoiled while typing this as I have no idea if you have finished FES or not. 
 
FES answered any questions I had, the exact reason for the graduation day scene put a tear in my honestly.

" I assume you mean the pre FES ending (I think?). I actually liked it for reasons I just almost spoiled while typing this as I have no idea if you have finished FES or not.  FES answered any questions I had, the exact reason for the graduation day scene put a tear in my honestly. "

The ending to The Journey was great. Obviously sad verging on depressing, and maybe a little confusing (it took me awhile to figure out exactly what just happened), but its pretty awesome. That and the general tone of the game are among the reasons I tend to like P3 over P4.
 
They kind of shat on that with The Answer, breaking the characters to contrive a little more gameplay. In the end, I just watched the highlights of it on Youtube, because even the gameplay was stupid difficult and repetitive beyond measure. I'd rather wrap my mind around some of the things that seem like missing plot points than to go through that.

" @Zenaxzd: Hum hum. That should have been in the Journey. Without it, it doesn't make much sense. "

I loved the ending of the journey, I thought it was a very fitting end to that game. And I have yet to play the answer yet.

" breaking the characters to contrive a little more gameplay "

" @Zenaxzd: Hum hum. That should have been in the Journey. Without it, it doesn't make much sense. "

I loved the ending. It's my favorite part of the game. After all the work and connecting with all your team members so much, it feels like the game's way of saying goodbye to it all. It may have been vague, but I couldn't have been more satisfied.