"But they could!"

Well once we see the Trophies for Cross Edge...

This is a pretty stupid idea.

No thanks. Rather a PS3 port w/ Trophies.

The game is fine where it is.

I like the idea of a persona game on this generation of systems, not that I don't like the idea of it remaining on the ps2. Even if it's a downloadable game like P3 is gonna be on the PSP I still wouldn't mind seeing what they could do with ps3/360 graphics...and of course the recognition of Trophies/Achievements would be fun too. Why? Why not?

The graphics are pretty dated for 'high definition' graphics quality. If anything, a Wii port would make more sense. Aside from a widescreen presentation, the game could benefit from menu controls with the pointer. Plus the remote can fit the whole TV theme of the game.
 
Otherwise, forget it. Not only is there no reason to port the game (Even though I wish it WAS on the Wii) Persona hasnt been on any other system. Atlus hardly ports their games to multiple consoles. Which is a shame. Maybe if the franchise was bigger. Either the SMT name or the Persona name, maybe we could see multi-platform ports.
 
Persona on the DS would be nice. You could have stats on one screen, with the action on the top screen. Things like that. But no, its all Sony systems.

Asking for a 360 port of P4 is right up there with asking for a Twilight princess port on the PS3. Utterly pointless and impossible.

Hell yes.

Seeing as I've seriously considered going and buying a PS2 just so I could play this, that would be awesome.