Damn does this game throw a shitload of choices at you, in a constant unrelenting stream.
To boot a lot of them are actually pretty hard for me to make.
I literally had to go for a walk outside for a couple of them to try to figure out in my head what would my Geralt do in those situations.

Don't remember the last time that the most difficult parts of an RPG were the actual role playing bits.
Feels kinda awesome!

Anyone else having a tough time, or second guessing their decisions?

Absolutely. The first game was much the same. It's one of few games that have really made the choices you make mean something. Sometimes in a very subtle way. There is a great article on RPS that explains it better than I can.

You just got me super pumped to pick this up tonight!

The lack of reviews has had my sense tingling, but damn do I like some RPG.