Whenever I try and view replay of the people at the top of the leader board, it's always broken.
 
Basically, it works for a few seconds and then glitches out and seems to reset the score or things aren't moving properly. The pause/play button doesn't work either. It seems to "play" when I pause it, except the screen freezes and the audio keeps going. It's very bizarre.
 
This happening to anyone else? I wanna see the top replay for Stampede and Keystone Kapers!

I haven't tried it for all games but it has worked every time i've watched replays. I've probably watched at least 20 or so. that's a bummer what's happening to you though.

That's happening with me too. I want to watch Pitfall replays to get better at my alligator head jumping skills, but the replays just keep glitching out. At first I thought it was to player actually using a glitch, so I got pissed, but it's also doing it for Yar's Revenge and Oink. It's really annoying.

Maybe the leaderboards are hacked which means there is no replay?