I've been going through the pro-keys trainer when I can (I think I'm about 50% done), and the suggestions for hand placement always show one hand. This feels a little weird. My left hand just kinda hangs out on the couch or somewhere else on the controller. And if it's a lower-octave part, I have to reach across my body or turn the keyboard toward my right hand for it to feel natural. Should I be using two hands and keeping them semi-still on the keyboard so that I can play all of the keys without moving? Or is this meant to be a 1-handed experience (aside from the stupid touch tremolo thingy)? I suppose in real piano, you would be using your left hand to play bass chords in most songs...
Rock Band 3
Game » consists of 14 releases. Released Oct 26, 2010
Rock Band 3 spices up the brand with the addition of a keyboard peripheral as well as "Pro Mode," and offers eighty-three new songs to rock out to.
Keyboard: 1 or 2 hands?
" I've been going through the pro-keys trainer when I can (I think I'm about 50% done), and the suggestions for hand placement always show one hand. This feels a little weird. My left hand just kinda hangs out on the couch or somewhere else on the controller. And if it's a lower-octave part, I have to reach across my body or turn the keyboard toward my right hand for it to feel natural. Should I be using two hands and keeping them semi-still on the keyboard so that I can play all of the keys without moving? Or is this meant to be a 1-handed experience (aside from the stupid touch tremolo thingy)? I suppose in real piano, you would be using your left hand to play bass chords in most songs... "I'd go for a mixture.
Depending on the song etc.. I haven't gotten the keyboard or the game yet (GIMME MA GAME) but when I do I'll probably play mostly with both hands.
For what I've been doing so far, one hand seems fine, even slightly easier. I can imagine hard and expert pro-keys almost requiring two hands though. Whatever feels right for each song and difficulty I guess.
" On Pro mode, the higher in difficulty you go, the more the part is meant to accurately mimic the real life right hand part of the piano score. Essentially, it's only meant to be played with one hand. "Wait, you mean to tell me pro keys has no left handed parts for songs coded in? Cause that would seriously cause me to reconsider getting a keyboard for RB3. I thought it was the full piano parts.
" @Vitor said:There aren't enough Keys on the instrument to do full piano parts - only 25 after all. I remember seeing an interview where they said that what you're playing on expert pro keys is essentially what you'd play in real life, but with one of the hands. Some songs might be left, others right, but you won't be playing the full piano part - that's not physically possible as it is with the pro guitar instruments." On Pro mode, the higher in difficulty you go, the more the part is meant to accurately mimic the real life right hand part of the piano score. Essentially, it's only meant to be played with one hand. "Wait, you mean to tell me pro keys has no left handed parts for songs coded in? Cause that would seriously cause me to reconsider getting a keyboard for RB3. I thought it was the full piano parts. "
If it's only 2 octaves using 2 hands for a long period of time would get uncomfortable. I guess it depends how large your hands are.
" @XII_Sniper said:Well they do have the MIDI pro adaptor for fullsized keyboards, so I thought that was going to be accommodated, but now that seems kindof pointless to do. I'll probably stick to drums." @Vitor said:There aren't enough Keys on the instrument to do full piano parts - only 25 after all. I remember seeing an interview where they said that what you're playing on expert pro keys is essentially what you'd play in real life, but with one of the hands. Some songs might be left, others right, but you won't be playing the full piano part - that's not physically possible as it is with the pro guitar instruments. "" On Pro mode, the higher in difficulty you go, the more the part is meant to accurately mimic the real life right hand part of the piano score. Essentially, it's only meant to be played with one hand. "Wait, you mean to tell me pro keys has no left handed parts for songs coded in? Cause that would seriously cause me to reconsider getting a keyboard for RB3. I thought it was the full piano parts. "
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Comment and Save
Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment