Which edition would be better?
I was planning out getting the GS Collectors edition but they are out of stock.
The collectors edition seems cool, but the pre-order order items from game stop seem really good.  Ideas?
 
Delete or Lock thread if need be.

Just pre-order from Gamestop if you can't get a copy of the collector's edition from Amazon.
 
Amazon might get a few more copies of the collector's edition back in today or Friday possibly, they did that with Mass Effect 2.

The fact that the preorder is a Armored Vault 13 suit sold me on GameStop. I'm still debating if I really want the CE or not. The graphic novel would be the only reason I would get it. You just have to figure out which you want more. Keep in mind that odds are good that all the preorder stuff may eventually become DLC. Like the horse armor from oblivion, which only cost money to create value for the fact you got it for free preordering the game.

I planned on picking up the CE from Amazon but decided against it for a couple reasons.  

A. It was technically being sold by Target through Amazon so my $20 credit from my Halo: Reach purchase would not have been applied

B. Being sold from Target they couldn't offer the $1 release date shipping so the only option was $20 1 day shipping. 

So in the end I settled on the standard edition for $41, I can live without the comic.  Though I would have really liked to see the items hid in game world revealed in the comic, that idea seems awesome.