If you had to take out a member and replace him...

I elect that Brad be replaced with Luchadeer.

" Not replace, but maybe put Brad on rotation. Drew and Dave should join the Bombcast more often. Oh, and Greg Kasavin. "

I want my Bombcast just the way it is.

I was gonna say Brad but then I remember his deep, manly voice and I was right back to square one. 
 
True answer - I wouldn't replace any of them.

I'd remove Jeff and give Snider more camera time.

Replace Brad (sorry Brad) with Ice T. 

If I had to, I'd replace everyone but Jeff and add Adam Boyes, Johnny V, and Alex.

Add Greg Kasavin, Tim Tracy, and maybe Michael Pachter to the mix and I will not have to listen to anything else for the rest of my life.

Get rid of Ryan...........................................

I'd replace Ryan with Brad, Jeff with Brad, and Vinny with... I'm gonna go with Brad. Brad's fine where he is.

I don't like this thread. The bombcast is only the bombcast because of all of the guys on it. And what's with all the Brad hate? He has to be one of my favorite of the group.

Nobody. These guys are amazing, and their chemistry together is what makes it such a great show. They've been in the business for a while and in it with each other for a while, so it's got a lot of character from that.

I would replace Ryan with another Brad...
 
I mean, I would replace everyone besides Brad, with another Brad.
 
... Brad's cute.

I would replace Brad with Dave. 

Giantbomb needs moar Dave.

too much brad hate in here! 
 
Replace no one, get a 5th AND 6th mic and get drew and dave in there. 6 man podcast go!

I'd replace Brad, Vinnie, and Jeff with Russian Martian Batman, Green Lantern Batman, and Regular-Ass Batman, and then replace Ryan with some sort of monstrous clone of all 4 of them, merged into one.

I'd take Ryan and replace him with Rich Gallup.

Replace Brad with a hot lady.

You can't replace Brad because he's always got the most well formed opinions of the bunch and probably the best taste in games. Vinny can't go either since he's normally the one to bring the comedic gold, plus his laugh is too infectious. 
 
@FreakAche said:

" I'd take Ryan and replace him with Rich Gallup. "

To everyone that suggested replacing Brad: 
 
  

" too much brad hate in here!
 
Replace no one, get a 5th AND 6th mic and get drew and dave in there. 6 man podcast go! "

Someone actually made this thread on their own site?  What are manners anyway?...

I'd just replace them all with Ice-T.  That's clearly all you really need.  

Michael Pachter and Sean Coonce should do a round table on wearing flip flops

Take out Ryan..I don't like him

" @FluxWaveZ: Upon considering things, replacing Vinny/Ryan/Jeff with 3 deep-voiced guys would be orgasmic. "

That's like asking what part of your penis you would slice 5 grams of flesh out of.

While I like the guys, Ryan can sometimes be a bit bitter and cynical.  Maybe Kat Bailey or Jeremy Parish from the Active Time babble podcast would be really nice.  Would be nice to get a JRPG fan on the discussion for once, they get skimmed over a lot usually.

I like Brad, but I also think that his personality is probably the most different out of everyone.
 
Also, while I like the crew as it is, you also have to accept the fact that one day in time one of them may leave to pursue a different career.  If that happens, I would want Jeff Green to be a member because I miss getting regular content from him.  Although I do agree that ideally a woman would be cool to join to add a new perspective to the boy's club.

Brad with Mila Kunis.  I heard she plays WoW.

I'd replace all of them with 4 drunk Leigh Alexanders.

" I'd replace all of them with 4 drunk Leigh Alexanders. "

Probably replace Jeff/Vinny with Greg Kasavin.

" I'd replace all of them with 4 drunk Leigh Alexanders. "

Replace Brad with Charlie Brooker for a month. In the meantime Brad presents screenwipe, JOB DONE.

" you might as well say, lets take one of the greatest voices of this or any generation and replace it with the sound of squirrels being thrown in to a meat grinder. "

" @Mikemcn said:

" you might as well say, lets take one of the greatest voices of this or any generation and replace it with the sound of squirrels being thrown in to a meat grinder. "

If I had a podcast, the sound of squirrels being thrown into a meat grinder would be one of the regular cast members. "

Yeah i wouldnt replace any of them, id maybe add Dave or Alex to the existing podcast but its fine as it is.  Id miss anyone that left...

Ryan Davis is kind of a dick sometimes so...........RIch Gallup

Replace Jeff with Dr. Tracksuit.  
 
If we're being serious, the team is pretty solid as-is. If I had to make a choice, I'd take out Brad and put in Dave. 

Replace Jeff with Dr. Tracksuit.  
 
If we're being serious, the team is pretty solid as-is. If I had to make a choice, I'd take out Brad and put in Dave. 

@Forum_User Goddamn it. I'm reading this on my phone at work, and I almost dropped my phone laughing. "

I wouldn't want to, but I'd probably choose Brad because he probably talks the least and replace him with John Davison!!!!!

I would replace Brad with Darb, who clearly is not Brad but with a fake mustache and glasses on and his name reversed... [Insert shifty eye movement here.] 

I just want more Dave on the podcast.

Brad with Greg Kasavin?  
 
I feel like Greg could play the arty one in place of Brad. He isn't great at talking on a podcast, though. 
 
Rich Gallup would be my choice just in terms of podcasting chops, but I don't know who I would trade him for.

Alternate reality, Rich Gallup hosts, still with the original four, but one of them cycles out each week. 
 
I can't take out any of them. A part of my soul will die if that happens.