• 85 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for big_denim
Posted by Big_Denim (840 posts) 10 months, 20 days ago

Poll: Do you listen to podcasts/videos while gaming? (409 votes)

Always 20%
Never 11%
Only during repetivie/grindy games 69%

Something I've noticed is many people saying, 'it's a good podcast game.'

Generally this is related to grindy games such as aRPGs, loot shooters, MMOs, etc.

It occurred to me that this is something I literally never do. Audio is a big part of my overall immersion in a game and I always feel like I'm missing out if I turn the volume down to focus on something else.

So do you listen to other things while playing grindy/repetitive/non-narrative games?

Avatar image for nutter
#1 Posted by nutter (2145 posts) -
No Caption Provided

Avatar image for theflamingo352
#2 Posted by TheFlamingo352 (349 posts) -

Instead of saying something is a podcast game, I should say what *isn't* a podcast game. Unless stuff like strong music or affecting moments are happening, I'm probably listening to something else. Witcher 3 and Divinity 2 are good examples of games like this, where my attention is rewarded well and often enough to discourage opening a podcast.

Avatar image for big_denim
#3 Posted by Big_Denim (840 posts) -

Wowzers, I didn't expect the 'Always' option to have so many votes. O_o

Avatar image for slag
#4 Posted by Slag (8157 posts) -

So I've done that before

and then I had an epiphany one day that I realized I didn't enjoy what i was doing. I wasn't getting full enjoyment out of the game and often totally missed what was being said in the podcast because focused on doing what I'm doing in the game. Worst of both worlds. I know people that feel completely differently, but that's how it was for me.

I realized I was only doing it because some games bored me enough that I needed more stimuli. So now I don't play grindy games like that much. I'll still occasionally play them (like Destiny 2) but only if I'm voice chat hanging out with friends.

Avatar image for nutter
#6 Posted by nutter (2145 posts) -

@slag: I like your styles, slag.

My wife asked me to watch It with her and surfed the web on her iPad the whole time. Do something or don’t, but don’t half-do a bunch of crap not interesting enough to hold your attention. Find something worth investing your time in.

Avatar image for xdeser2
#7 Edited by Xdeser2 (371 posts) -

Its hard for me to listen to podcasts without doing something else, whether its household chores, driving around or playing games, so I often seek out comfort food games like old RTS titles or games without any story to play in the background. The latest Breaking Brad put me back on a Rogue Legacy kick and its perfect for the bomb/beastcast.

Avatar image for nev
#8 Posted by Nev (778 posts) -

I wouldn't watch or listen to anything if I didn't. Story heavy games I don't, on my first playthrough, but everything else? Always either music, giantbomb, or television shows.

Avatar image for efesell
#9 Posted by Efesell (4508 posts) -

Absolutely Always.

There is no way I can just have one thing going on. I am never going to just play a game or just listen to a podcast or just watch a video.

Avatar image for captain_insano
#10 Edited by Captain_Insano (3513 posts) -

Depends on the game and the situation of the game. Story/Immersive games is pretty much always going to be a no. There are some exceptions to this, for example, in God of War, I listened to a podcast while grinding out Niflheim and Muspelheim, but nowhere else in the game did I listen to a podcast.

Ni No Kuni 2 I pretty much listened to a podcast for most of my play of it.

Sports or racing games I will as well. Strategy games too, though I'll often mute or pause for moments that require a bit more concentration.

Avatar image for harbinlights
#11 Posted by HarbinLights (194 posts) -

After about 600 hours of Splatoon on the Wii U, I got tired of the default music, and started listening to remixes and podcasts while playing.

Avatar image for facelessvixen
#12 Posted by FacelessVixen (2610 posts) -

I picked "Only during repetitive games," but "Always" would be more accurate. To an extent, I need to keep YouTube videos playing on my Surface 3 in order to keep track of time when I'm playing games while fixing my lunch or dinner, and also just to maintain a level of awareness for what's going on in and around my house since I don't like the notion of a game completely closing me off from the outside world. Also, the quiet time in certain games gets too quiet, particularly the time spent grinding in RPGs, the aforementioned "podcast games", and just games that I'm extremely familiar with in terms of time spent with either the genres of the games themselves that don't require my full attention. (Now that I think about it, I wonder if I can play Dark Souls 1 on autopilot.) More power to you "I need all of the immersion" and "I don't like splitting my attention" people, but I can't do that with games anymore.

Avatar image for harbinlights
#13 Edited by HarbinLights (194 posts) -

@facelessvixen said:

also just to maintain a level of awareness for what's going on in and around my house since I don't like the notion of a game completely closing me off from the outside world More power to you "I need all of the immersion" and "I don't like splitting my attention" people, but I can't do that with games anymore.

Personally, if I don't do that(immerse myself) in story based games, I've permanently spoiled the experience for myself.

I turn everything off and put my phone on silent for games like The Legend of Heroes.

Avatar image for poobumbutt
#14 Edited by poobumbutt (960 posts) -

@slag: I've also had something similar to this, but it's always game specific, rather than always being present. I'll try listening to the Bombcast while playing Furi or watching some QLs while playing Bayonetta and its always a one-track road to Frustration City.

I picked "only in repetitive games", but it would be more accurate to say "always, unless the game requires constant or focused attention". So, story-heavy games, ones with great atmosphere, or those that simply require my full attention are out. For example, I'll listen to a podcast/GB video/TV show while grinding out a level in Dark Souls. But once it's boss time? Video goes off and TV volume goes up, pay the fuck attention until Artorias sends me packing for the fiftieth time AND back to our regularly scheduled laziness.

I'm actually surprised how many people are as desperate for stimuli as I am. I always thought the feeling of "I NEED to be watching/listening to something else, I can't JUST be playing Enter the Gungeon" was an insane one unique to me. Glad that so very many others are head-cases too.

Avatar image for relkin
#15 Posted by Relkin (1184 posts) -

Audio is important for me too, but there are plenty of games where it just isn't necessary to the experience. In those cases, putting on an audiobook or a podcast is the way to go.

Avatar image for imhungry
#17 Posted by imhungry (1127 posts) -

I think it's actually the reverse for me, in that I game while listening to podcasts. When I'm playing a game, the default is generally to just listen to game audio but if I have a podcast I want to listen to and my commute time for the day is over I'll generally throw it on and play something low impact while listening like getting some Stardew Valley days done or clearing out fetch sidequests in whatever RPG is currently occupying my time.

Avatar image for rejizzle
#18 Posted by Rejizzle (1122 posts) -

Not usually during a narrative oriented game, but if I'm playing Civ or The Sims then yeah.

Avatar image for paliv
#19 Posted by Paliv (250 posts) -

I listen to podcasts while editing spreadsheets, cleaning, working out, doing yard work, that sort of thing. I actually like focusing on one media at a time though. I have so little time for games these days that if one is so unengaging that I need to have a podcast on, then it isn’t something I have time for.

Avatar image for frytup
#20 Posted by frytup (1316 posts) -

When I was playing a lot of WoW and Old Republic, I definitely listened to podcasts. Eventually I came to the conclusion that if a game is so boring/repetitive I can listen to podcasts while playing it, it's a waste of my time. Haven't touched an MMO since.

Avatar image for justin258
#21 Posted by Justin258 (15658 posts) -

If I'm just grinding away experience/money/resources in an RPG or something? Sure! I'll probably do this when I try to get the b-team leveled up in Octopath Traveler.

But generally I don't listen to podcasts while gaming. I've tried to before and I always find myself too disconnected from both to really care about either and I just wind up being annoyed.

Avatar image for clagnaught
#22 Posted by clagnaught (2122 posts) -

I do during GOTY or if I had a lot of podcasts lined up back to back. I only do it with repetitive games like tower defenses and such; not story games

Avatar image for frodobaggins
#23 Posted by FrodoBaggins (2064 posts) -

You people that picked always are animals! :P

Avatar image for fram
#24 Posted by Fram (1857 posts) -

I'll smash through podcasts while doing stuff around the house, cleaning, eating, or playing puzzle/twitchy/repetitive games like Path of Exile and Rocket League. Nothing like a bit of picross with a podcast!

But anytime I watch movie or TV show (or play a game with a story or mood) I'm all in on just that thing. The thought of playing something like Hollow Knight and losing out on the atmosphere is bizarre to me.

Avatar image for soimadeanaccount
#26 Posted by soimadeanaccount (617 posts) -

During repetitive and grindy moments for sure. It could be grinding in a hundreds hours long rpg or inventory management. Honestly I feel like podcasts are doing these games a favor because I usually can't stand grinding, and the podcasts make it way more tolerable.

I also listen to podcasts with less narrative focus games especially turn base strategy games like Civ and Xcom.

Avatar image for meierthered
#29 Posted by MeierTheRed (5942 posts) -

I only do it for games where i can switch my brain off and just focus on the podcast. Otherwise i retain nothing from them.

Avatar image for mattgiersoni
#30 Posted by MattGiersoni (587 posts) -

I don't for most games but I like to listen to my own music or podcasts in what I call "infinite" games, stuff like Gran Turismo Sport, Fifa, so racing games, sport games, sandboxy stuff like Minecraft, Stardew Valley, Cities Skylines (it has amazing OST but after 200 hours sometimes I need a change), MMOs are also one type. I can definitely divide my attention in a way that I don't lose focus on either the game or the podcast.

Avatar image for shagge
#31 Posted by ShaggE (9273 posts) -

I've bought games purely with podcasts in mind. But yeah, it's a case-by-case thing. Obviously I'm not going to mute the new AAA hotness to throw MBMBaM or something on, but some games are just perfect for it.

Avatar image for zombiepenguin9
#32 Posted by zombiepenguin9 (759 posts) -

If I'm playing an RPG and hit a grindy section of the game, or a particular play session ends up being more crafting/resource gathering/house-keeping focused, then I'll throw on a podcast or GB video. Otherwise, I prefer to focus on one thing at a time.

Avatar image for inresurrection
#33 Posted by Inresurrection (463 posts) -

@efesell: Man..... Is it an ADD problem or do you just not enjoy focusing on any one thing at all?

Avatar image for nodima
#34 Posted by Nodima (2614 posts) -

Like many others have said, situationally, for sure. My summers are dominated by Diamond Dynasty grinds and the audio commentary for MLB The Show has long reached a point of evergreen staleness. This is the first year I actually turned the commentary off, but there is still only so much low murmuring of a baseball crowd punctuated by cracked bats and slapped leather one can be reasonably entertained by.

I also turned to podcasts during times I was slogging away at question marks on the Witcher 3 map or completing menial tasks in God of War (in fact, God of War marking a turning point for me where I actually turned the subtitles on so I could keep listening to podcasts and not worry about missing the lake dialogues; I generally hate subtitles other than foreign films) but I typically play story heavy games with headphones on until the moment it potentially turns into more of a grind than an emotional experience.

I would never play games with an active narrative and listen to or watch something else at the same time, but I do also have to admit I'm less likely to start up a narrative-based game if I have a massive podcast or television backlog. There are a lot of games I'd love to play that I withhold from myself because I have too many Marc Maron episodes to get to.

Avatar image for efesell
#35 Posted by Efesell (4508 posts) -

@efesell: Man..... Is it an ADD problem or do you just not enjoy focusing on any one thing at all?

I guess? I dunno, I'm no specialist. I can split focus fairly easily between games and things like podcasts/videos so I just prefer to have multiple things going.

I wouldn't have thought it so strange of a thing. Surprised at the results of this poll honestly.

Avatar image for nutter
#36 Posted by nutter (2145 posts) -

@paliv: I hear ya.

Podcasts are for errands and driving around.

Music is for errands, driving around, and working out.

Avatar image for cubidog
#37 Posted by cubidog (96 posts) -

The vast majority of games I play are games that are perfect for podcasts. Rougelites, sandbox games like Minecraft and Terraria. Pretty much anything that doesn't have voice acting or a story that I need to pay attention to. I honestly don't remember the last time I played a game with a real story. It's probably been years, but that might be me just watching a ton of let's plays of those games on YouTube. I tend to enjoy watching somebody else play those games more than playing them myself.

Avatar image for gunner
#38 Posted by Gunner (4412 posts) -

I picked repetitive/grindy games only because I exclusively listen to podcasts while playing FIFA. I don't really have the means to listen to podcasts as I only have a 5 minute commute to work and I also work in the restaurant business. So a good session of FIFA, A couple beers and the most recent episode of the Bombcast or Beastcast is a great way to unwind after a long workday.

Avatar image for luchalma
#39 Posted by Luchalma (541 posts) -

Although I play and enjoy a large and eclectic mix of games, my taste in games essentially boils down to two types.

I like story heavy games where the mechanics are secondary (or tertiary) to interesting characters/dialogue/atmosphere. Your Witchers and Personas. And these are not podcast games.

Then the second group is roguelike/lites. Anything with procedural generation/permadeath. And in the beginning these games demand all my attention while I learn how the game works. But after a while they all become podcasts games as I bash my head against the wall until I break through.

Avatar image for ntm
#40 Posted by NTM (11826 posts) -

Never. I only want to play games I'm interested in, and if I'm interested in them, I want to hear them and nothing else really.

Avatar image for facelessvixen
#41 Posted by FacelessVixen (2610 posts) -

Personally, if I don't do that(immerse myself) in story based games, I've permanently spoiled the experience for myself.

I turn everything off and put my phone on silent for games like The Legend of Heroes.

*Google searches The Legend of Heroes*

Oh, sure. Mention an anime game to someone with an anime avatar. I see how it is.

Anyway. I will admit that having the Persona 4 Endurance Run play as background noise while playing Persona 4 Golden for the first time was tricky to avoid spoilers that weren't associated with "bitches and whores", and my attention wasn't as divided when shit was getting real starting the third chapter of Nier Automata.

Avatar image for harbinlights
#42 Posted by HarbinLights (194 posts) -

@harbinlights said:

Personally, if I don't do that(immerse myself) in story based games, I've permanently spoiled the experience for myself.

I turn everything off and put my phone on silent for games like The Legend of Heroes.

*Google searches The Legend of Heroes*

Oh, sure. Mention an anime game to someone with an anime avatar. I see how it is.

I highly recommend it. Particularly starting out with Trails in the Sky, the Steam version. It is, in my opinion, one of the best JRPGs of all time. Particularly in terms of world building and story writing.

Loading Video...

Avatar image for facelessvixen
#43 Posted by FacelessVixen (2610 posts) -

@harbinlights: Given my general opinion on JRPGs, I'll pass. I've been trying to change that negativity with Tales of Berseria, and Square is getting back on my good side with Final Fantasy XV on Steam, but my weeb interests in games are more aligned with Senran Kagura.

Also, come to think of it, I strongly prefer gameplay over story, which is probably another reason for why I can shift my attention since games that I'm good at playing don't need much of my concentration.

Avatar image for harbinlights
#44 Posted by HarbinLights (194 posts) -

I'll pass.

That's too bad. But I respect your tastes.

If you ever change your mind, it's definitely a best-in-genre game!

Avatar image for theht
#45 Edited by TheHT (15859 posts) -

Only during repetitive/grindy stuff. Diablo 3 is the best podcast/video game for me. Stuff like Monster Hunter: World and Absolver PVP though, I surprisingly prefer turning everything off when playing them, oftentimes even music. Somethin about em really makes me wanna zero in and focus.

Listening to podcasts/videos got to a weird place for me in the past though where I used to seek out grindy games so I could listen to stuff while playing, but then also seek out stuff to listen to just so I could play grindy games while listening to something/anything. Always tried to squeeze the most out of my time but ended up just feeling like I'd wasted it. To make matters worse I'd actively avoid playing something that demanded more attention because I didn't want to give up listening to something else, even though those kinds of games are far and away my preference. Mindlessly browsing Netflix is a similar kind of thing.

Online
Avatar image for fezrock
#47 Posted by Fezrock (731 posts) -

I started out only listening during repetitive/grindy games, but I've reached the point where its basically always. Which is problematic when its a game with a very strong story. I'm playing Yakuza 0 right now, and I've been forcing myself to turn off the podcasts at least during the cutscenes.

On the other hand, I also plan on picking on Monster Hunter World soon as it comes to PC, and I suspect that'll be a game I'll have no problem listening to podcasts during.

Avatar image for bladeofcreation
#48 Posted by BladeOfCreation (1342 posts) -

Yep! If I'm playing a game where I don't care so much about the story or dialogue, I'll often have the current week's GB content running in the background, and I alt-tab to the video if it sounds like something REALLY COOL is happening.

This sounds weird, and it is. Seriously. I started doing this about a year or so ago. Playing video content without actively watching the video?! I'm not saying it makes sense, it's just something I do.

Avatar image for deactivated-5b85a38d6c493
#49 Posted by deactivated-5b85a38d6c493 (1990 posts) -

Only during grindy games so MMOs or rogue likes are some examples. I rarely play those kinds of games anymore though.

Avatar image for the_greg
#50 Edited by The_Greg (542 posts) -

Answer 3 sums it up pretty much. I do listen to podcasts and sometimes I watch videos or even movies, but if there is any kind of story or gameplay that requires attention, I want to focus.

Most of the games I play these days are pretty mindless, as I just want to wind down for an hour here and there. Over the last couple of weeks, I've probably played video games for about 4 hours (a couple on No Man's Sky and a couple on Skyrim). I've listened to podcasts for that entire time.