@creepingdeath0 said:
Prizoner of Azkaban easily, 2nd place being tied between Philospher's Stone and Goblet of Fire.
I feel the series really went downhill after Goblet of Fire. Order of the Phoenix and Half Blood Prince just felt a bit too aimless and reliant on character deaths to me. As for Deathly Hallows... Camping diary anyone?
On top of those complaints, another issue with the books after Goblet of Fire is that Rowling seems to really expect the reader to remember all of the ancillary characters that were never very well established, and I really, really couldn't give a shit. "Oh man, surprise, Mrs. Figg saves Harry and Dudley from a Dementor. Isn't that awesome!?" No, it wasn't, it was stupid and random, and someone had to tell me that she had been briefly mentioned once back in like the first book. I think basically the more Rowling expanded the scope of the novels to include other aspects of her fictional wizarding world, the less cohesive or compelling it was. The series was best when it was focused on Harry and things happening at Hogwarts.
Goblet of Fire is basically the last time there was a memorable event going on at Hogwarts that defines the book. Philosopher's Stone didn't really need one because it has to establish the setting. Chamber of Secrets had people being petrified and the whole Slytherin's heir mystery. Prisoner of Azkaban had Sirius Black on the loose and all the Dementors and actually really well done time travel plot twists. And Goblet of Fire had the Triwizard Tournament, and introduced some non-UK characters into the Harry Potter fiction.
Then Order of the Phoenix is an entire book of nothing. Half-Blood Prince is about as boring, though I think the highlight was learning about Voldemort's weird past. And I think the Deathly Hallows just got way too far outside of what the series is about, though again I think the highlight was learning a bit about Dumbledore's weird past. Also, I really, really didn't care for all the prophecy bullshit that they kept harping on SO MUCH starting in Order of the Phoenix. It was bad in the way that most vague prophecies about the importance of the main character usually are.
Anyone voting for any of the last 3 books in this poll is a crazy person.
Log in to comment