Dude this is a weird thread. There are so many games each year that go by the wayside on this website. Hell man Persona 5 was my favorite game of last year and it got almost no recognition from these guys. It didn't stop me from playing it two more times after I beat it last year.
This just sounds like whining to me. The game is already getting nearly Universal praise everywhere else. Just enjoy the game you love man and if people agree with you cool. If they don't, you really don't know them so you have no real reason to be upset at their opinion. It just comes off as sort of creepy to be so upset that people you don't know, don't agree you. Stop expecting people to rub their genitals every time they mention something you like. Just do you.
It's definitely David Cage's best game. But when you compare it to everything else, that's not a super huge accomplishment. I guess it's the turd with the least amount of corn or most amount of corn. I guess that depends on your personal stance on corn.