@navster15: But why do that when you can just ignore their actual arguments and instead post a video by some random youtuber who also completely ignores the actual arguments? Better to show up, say you haven't learned anything about what's going on and no one can make you, and belittle everyone who is actually impacted by JK's actions.
So, I'm guessing this is directly addressing me since I'm the one who posted the video. Even though I didn't make the video, I do agree with the sentiment being expressed therein, which, in this forum, seems to have been ignored for the sake of vilifying potential customers and fans of an extremely popular media franchise that they like, because those people may not have the same strong feelings on the issue, but instead just want to play a game that they think looks fun and cool. I have not ignored any arguments on the matter as the quoted above purports, but I also don't feel the need to engage in arguments that will just be ignored by those who simply want to argue. I do not decry anyones opinion, want, or need to personally boycott, or even form boycott groups for greater impact towards their goal of trying to cancel an author who has essentially already been cancelled in the court of public opinion. However, I do not agree with nor tolerate attacks or villainization on people who are not directly attacking a particular group, which has been what has happened since the discourse over this game began. Like the creator of the video, I am black, and if I advocated the types of actions I have seen perpetrated online in response to "potential customers" of this game, towards people who indirectly have supported companies and creators who have spoken or effectuated actual violence on my people, a lot of you choosing to die on this hill, would die on a hill. I have seen support for posts by people in online communities who have said, "I hope that anyone who plays or plans to play Hogwarts legacy unfollows me and dies". This is not the way to gain or foster support for your cause, and actually only serves to galvanize people into opposition of your cause on principle, based on those actions. By all means, have and express your opinions, create your protests and boycotts, but calling out, attacking or doxxing people who may not agree with you, who are not directly harming you, is where the line should be drawn.
Log in to comment