I am pretty sure these have all been said but....
I agree with everyone else on Dominion. It's technically a card game but too good to not be mentioned. That game has tons of replayability and isn't all about dicking people over as much as it is creating your own strategy.
Pandemic is good so long as one person isn't overbearing in your group. It can very easily turn from everyone working together to cure diseases to one guy just listing commands for people to do on their turn. Forbidden Island is very similar but also good and short.
Puerto Rico and Settlers of Cataan are great for 3-5 people as well and usually don't take too long once everyone playing understands the rules.
Log in to comment