Ok, so I need to forefront this by saying I am not defending the issues with this game, especially the sound design, I am not a shill for the devs, and I am not trying to say this game is worth your time if you don't already think it is.
What I would like to talk about is the sadness that I have found in watching how this game has been reviewed.
I'll start with a simple premise...when was the last time a game made for early teens was cool? I can't think of any post-fortnite game that isn't some remake for nostalgia (ctr racing etc). I'm sure there are a few but I cant think of them.
A big problem here is the advertisment of Biomutant, it did not make itself out to be a game for 10-15 year olds, and maybe it was hoping it wouldn't exclusive be so, but it kind of is, and even though there might be enjoyment to be had for an older seasoned gamer here it's at its core quite simply a game for kids. And that should be OK!
So why are the reviews bad? Well because they simply aren't acknowledging the obvious target demographic, which isn't them. Why is this sad? Well because why the fuck should 10-15 year olds not get a cool game without being told by the youtubers they watch that their game is too easy, and lacking, and not 'narratively engaging'. It just sucks, it's like saying yo swings are shit, stop enjoying swings.
There are a few reviews I've seen that understand this, Worth a Buy and ACG are both great and talk about the game as an objective product while giving their opinions in a way that makes sense if you are familiar with them, a style of review that makes GB so useful as a guide (pretty sure Biomutant is on paper a Jason game). Maybe I'm over thinking this or just want something to be better than it is, but I can't help feeling that there is this big 'its not what i want it to be' vibe happening and c'mon dudes let the kids have theirs!
Looking forward to hearing the GB talk on this which i gues is out there now, really would like Brads take I think he would be the one to put it in perspective for me.
Log in to comment