Samantha and Leigh are right to speak out against the idiots who are verbally assaulting them today, but I'm a little concerned about Leigh's tweet (I guess since deleted), that "literally everything I write is more interesting than everything most of the GB staff does". Calling out "the GB community", while reductive, is appropriate today - but insulting the actual GB staff like that?
At the end of the day, as Jeff et al. have said repeatedly over the years - Giant Bomb is a personality-driven site, so it makes sense that Jeff would hire people he knows very well, and thus thinks will mesh well with what they are doing. There is absolutely an element of unconscious institutional discrimination to this, because white male writers become friends with other white male writers due to the lack of diversity in the games journalism profession. It becomes a self-sustaining loop, that makes it unduly hard for women and minorities to "break in" to the industry. Acknowledging that fact should not sign you up for an avalanche of hatred.
However, I also earnestly struggle with the idea that Jeff should have consciously decided to hire a certain demographic (though that raises the further question of "then how does it ever get fixed?"). I think people should be hired for Giant Bomb, depending on how well they think the personality will fit. If they hired Cara Ellison as a writer tomorrow (in the same vein as Scoops), I'd be thrilled, because I think she's cool, and a good writer. I think Ryckert was a great hire, because of his interests and personality, and his rapport with the GB guys - and because he has no doubt been signed up to do lots of on-camera work with the guys, where that rapport is important.
At the end of the day, this whole shitstorm is just disappointing, and has overshadowed a couple of great hires I was excited about. I get that some people jump to defend the GB guys, because they perceive them to be getting "attacked" despite not doing anything "wrong", but they are more than capable of taking criticism, and answering it if they decide it needs to be. As for the misogynists in our midst - maybe go find another website to pollute, if you haven't already.
Log in to comment