Hi guys, please forgive me for doing this. I've a question that's itching the inside of my skull something fierce and I'd really appreciate some counter-thoughts. In other words, please school me. Civilly ;P
When is cultural appropriation okay? The other day I was thinking about Día de Muertos, which is and always has been a super rad tradition, both superficially and at depth. Is it okay to adopt this as a celebration if you’re from a different culture? What about cooking? There’s amazing Native American food, Vietnamese food is incredible, and I grew up head over heels in love with Italian cooking. What about words? There are ways to express certain things in English that can’t really be done elegantly in my native Norwegian, and English itself appropriates words from other languages to do the same. This chain of appropriating expression is, at this point, core to how I express myself. But how are these things not appropriating foreign culture?
My interpretation, as of now, is that the power dynamics of me being a white dude mean I racially carry some stigma of being “a conqueror” and therefore me integrating culture of “the conquered” as my own affirms my "conqueror" status. That’s my understanding. But my actual gut feeling, aligned to my moral compass, is that loving and appreciating something is not deprecating of its origins, but celebratory. Conversely, it seems bizarre to me to segregate culture, literally the color of our entire species, into camps. I feel all culture should be archived and documented and remembered and shared, and appreciated as part of the great work of our species. That we should keep it all in little racially defined display cases and shame each other for wanting to touch it seems like doing the thing itself a disservice. Who really stands to benefit here?
I’ve had colossal arguments with people over this stuff in the past so I’m assuming I’m in some ignorant minority. I just hate the idea of dividing our species into ethnically or culturally defined enclaves and doubling down on our differences, when the light of any culture does nothing but bring color to those adjacent. I just don’t understand this isolationism, and it's made me really weary of taking part in some things that I love or want to learn more about, and that makes me sad.
Is my definition completely off?
Log in to comment