riostarwind's Shenmue (Dreamcast) review

Avatar image for riostarwind

What this game managed to do on the Dreamcast was very impressive. Now does all that ambition turn into a fun game?

No Caption Provided

Going back to this game really shows off how much it expected players to take their time. Spend some time just improving moves and exploring the small town they handcrafted with a bunch of details. Sure it has a Virtua Fighter like combat system but you’ll barely even get to use it till the final section of the game. Most of what you end up doing is just talking to NPC's. When it was first released that was amazing yet looking at it now it sounds & looks dated. But first let me go over what's going on in the world of Shenmue.

Side quest about taking care of a cute kitten? Hard to not love that no matter what year I'm playing this.
Side quest about taking care of a cute kitten? Hard to not love that no matter what year I'm playing this.

Ryo is a young man who is living his normal life until one day a mysterious man named Lan Di showed up to kill his father. As you might expect Ryo didn’t take this lying down and from that day onward he decided to hunt this killer down. Even with his Hakuzi martial arts training he wasn’t quite sure if he’ll be able to succeed but some friends made along the way might make a difference.

Once all the drama ends an entire little town opens up to be explored. Each character is voice acted well enough for the time. Although the audio quality sounds really rough now. It really seems like the goal was to impress the player with all the different things you can look at along with the graphical style. At the time it was very good but it’s hard not to see how dated it looks now. Thus leaving the game to rely on its characters. Yet no one really gets much of an arch. Sure the game does add some depth to a few main characters yet most don’t do much other than say they know nothing about sailors or whatever Ryo is after at the time.

The fighting part does seem like it’s robust until you never get much of a chance to test your skills in anyway till the endgame. I honestly think I spent more time just practicing moves in game to waste some time till the next story bit happens. Spending hours of in game time just training up moves does have a zen like quality to it. Plus the moves do change if you master them. Still a lack of stuff to do in game is a bummer when it expects you to wait around constantly. The pace is just glacial compared to more modern games.

Racing forklifts was really silly. Working a day to day job had some Harvest Moon like charm to it.
Racing forklifts was really silly. Working a day to day job had some Harvest Moon like charm to it.

Overall the best stuff is just all the little things on the side. Being able to play Hang-On and Space Harrier in game was a fun time. Collecting capsule toys was amazing for a while too. Yet other than becoming a dock worker near end game that really is just about all your options for stuff to do other than figure out the next clue. While certainly not realistic some more possible fights could have alleviated some of the downtime a bit better. Plus like 30% of all fights are just QTE moments. Which does bring up one really good fact. This game doesn’t waste your time if you do lose. Either the fight wasn’t a fail state or it just loads up right where you left off. In a game that does want me to wander about it was nice to see this little time saver.

Looking over everything this game has offered has made me come to a very simple conclusion. This is a product of its time. A video game that is very hard to go back and play now. Unless you played this when it originally came out I highly doubt it’ll be worth checking out today. Yet it certainly left an impression on me since I pretty much remembered every scene of the game 10 years later. So yeah, while it may not be a great game anymore it does have value as a nostalgia piece. After all I did play all the way through this even though my review does have a negative tone. So this game does certainly do something that captivates players.

3 Comments

Avatar image for monkeyking1969
MonkeyKing1969

8260

Forum Posts

1241

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 17

Yeah, I replayed Shemue in late last year. I have to say I got bored. Some of ist was replaying the game for what must have been teh third time, but some of it was the game did feel very dated. I have a much better time currently with Yakuza. But, I will readily admit I love teh forklift job- I like mini-games like that.

I will play Shenmue 3, I backed the KS for PS4. But, if it too clunky I will not about finishing it. I'd rather pick up Yakuza 6 or Yakuza Kiwami 2. But, I will give Yu's game a sold shot. I like that he was given a chance to do some more of the story, it is not Shakespeare, but it was fun enough as a narrative.

Avatar image for riostarwind
riostarwind

1391

Forum Posts

8479

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 204

User Lists: 60

riostarwind  Moderator

@monkeyking1969: I do plan on playing Shenmue 3 as well. I'll likely wait till it goes on sale at some point but I am curious to see if it really just ends up being more of the same. I do like that we are getting more of Yu's vision. But I wish he would have condensed it a bit more. Unless something changed I don't think we are going to get a satisfying conclusion in S3. I would love for the new game to sell well but it very much seems like the only way we are going to get the full story is if it was turned into a novel.

Avatar image for monkeyking1969
MonkeyKing1969

8260

Forum Posts

1241

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 17

No Caption Provided

@riostarwind: I suppose you are right, getting a conclusion that 'works' will be a hard get. I certainly feel bad for the people who were promised a 'Steam" release and won't get it right away. There is no upside for teh customers on that.

Yet, within the bounds of it own impossibility, I'm sort of happy, despite all logic, there will be a third game. It is like one of those Ripley's Believe it or Not! comics.


Other reviews for Shenmue (Dreamcast)

    I have three words: Must Find Sailors 0

     Shenmue is a very divisive game for many gamers who have played it. On one hand, you have a group of people who declare that the game’s slow, methodical pace makes it a chore to play. On the other hand, you have a group of people who proudly declare it’s methodical pace as the entire reason the game is so engrossing – that it really helps draw the player in with a daunting level of realism. Regardless of what opinion you may have on the game, there’s no denying that Shenmue tried to do a lot of...

    3 out of 3 found this review helpful.

    You are Ryo Hazuki 0

    Ryo Has Revenge in his eyesShenmue is a mash up of different types of genre's that come together to create something unique and special. As one of the most expensive games to be made, it captivated those who played it, including me. In my opinion, it truly is a classic.The plot for Shenmue starts out basic enough. Your Father is killed by a man named Lan Di, and Ryo Hazuki decides to track him down and avenge his father's death. Finding Lan Di won't be easy, and you'll need some information. Mak...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.