Obviously since I'm asking about achievements I'm playing this on 360, I'm just trying to clean up the rest of what I have left to get the 1000/1000. I have been working towards getting all the unique weapons and I had 1 left to go: the Grant. So I got down to TotG and got through it no problem, had Paladin Leroy invade and killed him, got the Grant and... well, nothing. I've read and re-read the list of weapons required to get the achievement, and that was the last one I needed. Has anyone else had problems getting that achievement to pop? Kinda sucks when I'm getting so close to finishing it all and then something like this happens, hopefully I just need to do something silly like walk into a different area or go kill something real quick. It was definitely a little upsetting.

@LookItsPineapple said:

Obviously since I'm asking about achievements I'm playing this on 360, I'm just trying to clean up the rest of what I have left to get the 1000/1000. I have been working towards getting all the unique weapons and I had 1 left to go: the Grant. So I got down to TotG and got through it no problem, had Paladin Leroy invade and killed him, got the Grant and... well, nothing. I've read and re-read the list of weapons required to get the achievement, and that was the last one I needed. Has anyone else had problems getting that achievement to pop? Kinda sucks when I'm getting so close to finishing it all and then something like this happens, hopefully I just need to do something silly like walk into a different area or go kill something real quick. It was definitely a little upsetting.

http://darksoulswiki.wikispaces.com/Knight's+Honor+Achievement+Guide

Check that list please.

There are two versions of Greatsword of Artorias

OH!!! Ok thanks, that reminded me that I didn't get the True Greatsword of Artorias yet. I have the broken sword leveled up to +10 and ready to go, but I'm going to have to finish NG+ and go beat Sif a 3rd time to get that. Fuck thats going to take longer than I'd wanted. Thanks though for reminding me about it.

I didn't get the achievement for reaching Anor Londo until my new game plus, so that's pretty weird.

@biggiedubs said:

I didn't get the achievement for reaching Anor Londo until my new game plus, so that's pretty weird.

Same for me.

Worked normal for my brother though.