mikeinsc's Duke Nukem Forever (Xbox 360) review

Brand New...Yet Old

I'll avoid the usual list of things that have happened since Duke Nukem Forever was announced (OK, just for giggles, I'll remind people that President Clinton got impeached since the game was announced, to give an idea how long this has been in developmental hell). Gearbox decided to pick up the pieces from whatever the heck 3D Realms was doing besides releasing games or finishing this repeatedly-rebuilt-from-scratch game of infamy. And the game will likely sell pretty well simply because it is such a known commodity in the world of gaming --- not known, necessarily, for good things, mind you.
 
You start off at the end of one of the levels of Duke Nukem 3D (the game is 15 years old...I do not remember what level had this boss in it). It turns out that you are Duke, playing your game while twin pop divas are busily pleasuring you. The game deserves SOME credit for giving you an idea of the kind of game this will be early on. You then have a story mentioned that is quickly forgotten about as the developers clearly believed that cheesy one-liners are the same thing as a plot.
 
In a nutshell, the game is bad. In its defense, its series wasn't exactly known for a series of great games. Duke Nukem 1 and 2 were mediocre at best and 3D, while great, still qualifies as the only openly good game in this God-forsaken franchise. Tony Hawk has a better success rate than Duke has, and that was over way more games. 
 
Since the game doesn't care about its plot, I will not pretend to do so, either. And while I'm also fairly sure it doesn't care about its gameplay EITHER, I cannot really ignore that aspect. The game feels really, really janky and old. The jankiness isn't a huge stunner given this title's notoriously disastrous development cycle, but it is not something that can be excused. Your weapons don't feel powerful as the enemies just die and it feels like it was almost in spite of your weapon being fired. You don't feel like your guns have any impact to them whatsoever. Enemies don't react to fire outside of their death animations --- which look about 15 years old. You can shoot some of the enemies with the Ripper a dozen times and they are not impacted at all...right until the point where they die. 
 
The levels are, sadly, really bad. I know older games actually tended to have more complex level design than modern games do (most gamers don't have the patience for the "interesting" level design choices that populated games in the past), but this game has a basically totally linear path with puzzles that aren't exactly solved with intuitive logic. They took the worst parts of old shooters and combined them with the worst aspects of old adventure games to give us the best of both worlds here. You go through strip club, Hoover dam, unbelievably dull caves, Duke Burger joints, etc. 
 
You are even given an underwater level which might be the single worst level I've played in a game in years. Duke runs out of air really thin --- and when you are fighting difficult enemies WHILE running out of air, it does make the battle way more irksome than compelling. I hated Sonic's underwater levels badly enough, but this is a character who is supposed to be nearly superhuman who can hold his breath for less time than my 6 year old can.
 
Visually, the game looks like an early PS2 game. Environments look dull. Textures are bland. Physics are seldom present outside of one or two puzzles. Enemies look rather bad. The character models that they did spend some time on --- ALSO look really bad and out-of-date. The "sexy" women look like dead people. But, hey, at least it is longer than your usual FPS, which is always a good sign when your game is also pretty boring and dull. 
 
I cannot recommend this game. I liked Duke Nukem 3D a lot when it came out --- but the game business has improved exponentially since then while this game feels like a game made in 1996 with slightly improved visuals. But, it will sell well enough to generate a sequel and, God willing, that sequel won't be tied to a really failed design as this game was and end up becoming playable. But DNF is not good. Easily one of the least compelling games of the year.

0 Comments

Other reviews for Duke Nukem Forever (Xbox 360)

    Alright! Duke is back! 0

    The only reason I didn't give it a 1 star is because I'm a Duke fan boy. The bugs are crazy but not game breaking... sadly. It looks so bad. Like most people... I'm holding out hope for a better Duke game. If you missed this one... try to keep it that way.Pros - You get to play Duke freaking Nukem again!Cons - The game... its all a con... all of it......

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Well, it's a game. 0

    Duke Nukem Forever excels at one specific thing: Making the act of alien genocide fun as hell. All of the weapons have a great feel to them, and even the starting pistol packs a punch. Unfortunately, Duke Nukem Forever really wants you to do things other than shoot aliens, and that's it's biggest downfall.  12 years after the events of Duke Nukem 3D, Duke is now a mega-celebrity. Girls want him, guys want to be him. About 5 minutes after pressing start, aliens invade earth, steal our chicks, and...

    3 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.