Layout of the sandwich (as per Bennigans recipe):
- Powdered sugar (sprinkled after fried)
- Wheat Bread
- Ham
- Turkey
- Swiss cheese
- American cheese
- Wheat bread
- Ham
- Turkey
- Swiss cheese
- American cheese
- Wheat bread
Bennigans would cut it in half (diagnally) fry the two halfs separately, and cut those in half and serve. [In case you are curious/want to make one, the batter consists of: 1.5 cup flour, 1 tsp baking powder, a pinch of salt, 2/3 cups water. Put the batter around the 2 pieces, and wrap in seran wrap and put in fridge for an hour or longer (to soak into the bread) before frying]. Bennigan's made the mistake of serving it without powdered sugar once and I personally found it tasted very strange (though I was used to the taste by then) I had to get them to bring me some. Yes it did sound odd when I first ordered it, but I liked all the ingredients so I went at it.
My friend and I use to go to Bennigan's, eat a pick 3 appetizer and each buy a monte cristo and finish all of it without regret. The times we most regretted it were the first couple times, and any time we had a lunch that was sizable before visiting Bennigans for dinner :)
Bennigan's went out of business so my fiance and I make them at home now.
Monte Cristo followup.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment