@rigas it's not a software update that's why I am trying to say. Software update means you need the original stuff to apply the update. Thief: Gold is not an "update" that you can add on an existing Thief: The Dark Project. It is a separated game. You can't create a TG from a TDP with an update or something. TG was sold as a separated CD and jacket. So technically speaking, it is a standalone game.
Also btw I see that this logic isn't always applied for all games. @arbitrarywater I'm glad you took an example of another game cause I noticed indeed some of the game in the database could be considered as "extensions" but are still separated stuff. For instance Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City https://www.giantbomb.com/grand-theft-auto-episodes-from-liberty-city/3030-26616/ is clearly described as a "disc-based product consisting of the two DLC packs for Grand Theft Auto IV. It includes both Grand Theft Auto: The Lost and Damned and Grand Theft Auto: The Ballad of Gay Tony. The achievements for the game will not be separate and will add on to GTA IV's achievements."
If I read again what you wrote it can hardly be considered as a standalone game as it is a merge of two DLC's, and still it's separated in teh database. And there are other examples like that. If this one is legit to be separated, I believe TG is even more considering TG was never an "official extension" but a "official new game" .
@arbitrarywater concerning the differences between the two games, there are a lot. From an external point of view, I understand it feels like "it's just a fix of TDP" but I spoke about it to the Thief community, and they agree with me that it is much more. I mean there are more missions but also more stuff on the lore. And also new stuff in the mission That already existed in TDP. In term of gameplay, it makes a big difference. In the database, there is many unlisted differences. Taking in account all of these, I think there is enough to separate the two.
So, if we talk in term of "extension", "DLC" etc., I'm 100% TG can be separated, cause it is definitely an official standalone game.
Now if we talk in term of degree of difference the debate is a bit more tricky. I still think there are enough difference to justify a separation, but if you want I can give you a precise list of teh changes and you can judge by yourself ?
Log in to comment