Husky or HD - Starcraft commentary

Who is better at commentating Starcraft, I have watched quite a lot of video's from both and I prefer HD's style... although I do think HD is going slightly insane from covering too many video's.. last week he woke at 4am and needed to start calling some SC games which seems a bit wierd :P
Husky is ok, he finds himself too funny for me to find him funny, but when in full commentator mode I like his tone and knowledge but HD is better at disecting a game.

HD is much better than husky. HD is classy, sophisticated, and he still says the stupidest stuff, but on accident. lIke "its going to be a big crap-a-doodoo". Where Husky tries way to hard and is kind of a jerk.

I like Husky's tangents myself. HD is perfectly fine as well, although sometimes his attempts at humor fall very flat and awkward for me.

" I like Husky's tangents myself. HD is perfectly fine as well, although sometimes his attempts at humor fall very flat and awkward for me. "

HD is generally more detached and level-headed when narrating the match, making him the superior choice if you're interested in the specifics of each player's strategies, maneuvers, and how the game was won.  However, Husky is more entertaining and invested in the game. 
 
No preference, then.

Both inferior to Day9 but I prefer H to the usky to HD.

I find Husky annoying, so I'd go with HD. Having said that, I prefer watching Psy and JoshSuth's casts.

What? Why choose?

" Both inferior to Day9 but I prefer H to the usky to HD. "

HD has terrible vocabulary and has very little insight on the game. I would say he's really good for players who don't know much about the game or just want a play by play of whats going on. But really, the fact that he's been commentating for so long yet knows so little + provides incorrect analysis is kinda weird. Husky is a little more knowledgable about the game but also doesn't provide great analysis. Overall theyre both really fun to watch but for commentators with better game sense, watch day9, psystarcraft, and tasteless + artosis

I prefer HD. Day9 is the best though. The day9+ HD team at one of the tournaments was some of the best casting I've seen

Tebjz when he gets around finishing the single player.

" HD has terrible vocabulary and has very little insight on the game. I would say he's really good for players who don't know much about the game or just want a play by play of whats going on. But really, the fact that he's been commentating for so long yet knows so little + provides incorrect analysis is kinda weird. Husky is a little more knowledgable about the game but also doesn't provide great analysis. Overall theyre both really fun to watch but for commentators with better game sense, watch day9, psystarcraft, and tasteless + artosis "

I'm still waiting for the Plott brothers to cast together, Day9 + Tasteless cast would be epic. Possibly only eclipsed by a Tri-cast of Tasteless Artosis and Day9.

Another great commentator is Rise.  http://www.youtube.com/sc2ggrise 
 
He is one of the funniest casters ever and is a really nice guy. Unfortunately he won't be casting anymore, which kinda bummed me out I've honestly grown to love his random tangents that he'd go off on during games. The games are pre release when strategies weren't so developed and people had no idea how to play the game, so its pretty interesting

" HD has terrible vocabulary and has very little insight on the game. I would say he's really good for players who don't know much about the game or just want a play by play of whats going on. But really, the fact that he's been commentating for so long yet knows so little + provides incorrect analysis is kinda weird. Husky is a little more knowledgable about the game but also doesn't provide great analysis. Overall theyre both really fun to watch but for commentators with better game sense, watch day9, psystarcraft, and tasteless + artosis "

Tasteless > all

I havent seen any commentators with a real commentary voice. I hate the guys who currently do them. They sound like such assholes.

Both are enjoyable by me. but i do like HD just because he seems to keep up with the action and gives some good input.

tasteless has a real commentary voice, he sounds incredibly professional

Why the fuck do you have to choose its not like either of them make too many videos to where you can't watch both.

" HD has terrible vocabulary and has very little insight on the game. I would say he's really good for players who don't know much about the game or just want a play by play of whats going on. But really, the fact that he's been commentating for so long yet knows so little + provides incorrect analysis is kinda weird. Husky is a little more knowledgable about the game but also doesn't provide great analysis. Overall theyre both really fun to watch but for commentators with better game sense, watch day9, psystarcraft, and tasteless + artosis "

" Why the fuck do you have to choose its not like either of them make too many videos to where you can't watch both. "

" I prefer HD. Day9 is the best though. The day9+ HD team at one of the tournaments was some of the best casting I've seen "

I cannot stand Husky. Every time I hear that H to the usky shit I want to kill myslef.

HD is the better commentator knowledge wise, but i love Husky because he has a tendancy to go absolutely crazy in important battles.

" @bananablade said:

" HD has terrible vocabulary and has very little insight on the game. I would say he's really good for players who don't know much about the game or just want a play by play of whats going on. But really, the fact that he's been commentating for so long yet knows so little + provides incorrect analysis is kinda weird. Husky is a little more knowledgable about the game but also doesn't provide great analysis. Overall theyre both really fun to watch but for commentators with better game sense, watch day9, psystarcraft, and tasteless + artosis "

This man knows his casters. You earn my seal of approval. "

" @Pointsman said:

" I prefer HD. Day9 is the best though. The day9+ HD team at one of the tournaments was some of the best casting I've seen "

watching some of the day9 stuff now.. yea he seems really good, instead of being a general commentator it seems he is more interested in game mechanics and gameplayh decisions which is cool. "

I like HD more than Husky
Gotta go check out these other commentators though

I prefer Day9 and Tasteless over Husky or HD but I think they're all pretty damn good to be honest.

HD is way more proffesional than Husky, but I still like Husky more since he is way funnier.

lovin day9, awesome cheers!

Gary Busey is really good.

I don't want lame jokes from commentators. 
 
All I want is for them to stay focused on the match and provide insight into the game, and more importantly thoughts on what the players are thinking. Anyone can see "what" is happening on the screen, the value of the commentator is explaining the "why".