@bladededge said:
@beachthunder: Over christmas break, over a long week-end, as an alternative to E3 over-load? Sure, why not.
That said, throwing the single longest thing they have done at me as the example you cite as why what I say is unreasonable doesn't really invalidate my point. Do I want to see 4 days worth of P4? not often, once a year maybe, so don't have it come up often.
Do I care to have the chance to vote for one of the many 8-12 hours LPs they have in order? Absolutely.
Why does that need to be on GBTV, though? Why is that better than just running a playlist on your own time? Are people actually going to hang out in a chat for four days waxing nostalgic, or will there naturally come a point where that's just not fun anymore? Is that a fun way to introduce new people on an old series, or is that just for people who are watching it for the 10th+ time? Granted, I'm biased because I've never been a fan of the extended-series-playing-one-game shows anyway, especially not the ERs or anything Dark Souls, so any time any of that content comes up in GBTV I immediately check out, but it feels to me like what you want is a super specific thing that's not best served by GBTV.
I definitely feel like there's a smarter way of doing GBTV than the current system, as it's being pulled in too many different directions. I'm not a fan of episodes from series being played out of order, but I also don't necessarily want that whole series to play out marathon style. I'm also picky about what long-form content I'm interested in; like I said, ER can stuff it, but any old Dave Random PC game or obscure TNT and I'm all over it. UPF is definitely a problem, because the nature of the show means it's quite hit-or-miss, and the fact that just the date shows up on polls with no more context is not helpful at all. And I think pretty much everyone agrees that any long-form video that gets played twice in a short time span, such as last night when ep. 3 of the 2011 SNES marathon stream - a 3-hour video - was picked twice in a 12-hour period, is just not fun.
Part of the problem is the polls. It encourages people to make snap judgements, rather than actually think about what would be the best content for GBTV. I know that polls is something they're working on, but the system is definitely too open right now, and smarter filtering of chat options should be a high priority.
As for the long-play stuff, I almost feel like it should operate more like a TV channel, where at a certain time people know a long-form video is going to run like a TV movie, so at 12am and 12pm there is a 2+ hour video and there is a vote for which video people want. This is also how series could work; there could be a time-slot where people know a series is running, and that lets things play out in order without disrupting anything else. And the rest of the time is for shorter videos like QLs, previews, TANG, etc. I realise this would require much more engineering wizardry than the current system, but I really don't feel like GBTV can reach its true potential without some more curation and oversight on what content people get to vote on.
Log in to comment