Will Read Dead Redemption be good?

Despite all the controversy over the game will it be a game I need to buy?

No.

No. 
 
It'll be great.

" No.  It'll be great. "

yes

It sure is taking it's sweet ass time, I'm not hyping myself up but I am definitely interested in it.

Read Dead Redemption? Is that like a reading instructor game?

Let me just hop in my time machine...
 
Seriously though, from what we've seen, it looks promising.

It's about the rise of history's dead literary geniuses, grasping with their decayed ligaments at the public which ignored them until long after their demise.

i'm totally hyped for it. but i have no console except for the wii D:

I have it on definitive authority that Jeff will accept it as a legitimate response to "what is the greatest video game of all time?"

I think it's safe to say that it will be nothing short of awesome.