#1 Edited by Fitzgerald (386 posts) -

Who is better?

Edit: I don't know how to create a poll.

#2 Posted by Terramagi (1168 posts) -

You have 60-70 hours to grow attached to Nanako. As such, the attachment has time to grow naturally, even if the "you will love this fucking character god dammit" is being laid on PRETTY THICK.

Telltale did much the same thing with Clementine, except they only had 8-10 hours with her. So they laid it on so thick that you can get diabetes just looking at her for too long.

#3 Posted by RetroVirus (1559 posts) -

Nanako all the way. She LOVES that Junes.

#4 Posted by musclerider (633 posts) -


#5 Posted by Captain_Felafel (1695 posts) -


#6 Posted by AlisterCat (6214 posts) -

Nanako is a moron, but a loveable moron.

#7 Posted by Sidoran (85 posts) -

I'm throwing in my vote for Nanako. She's just more naturally endearing to me while not even seeming like a major character for much of the game.

I like Clementine a lot too but she felt a little more forced.

#8 Posted by yoshimitz707 (2532 posts) -

Everyday's great at your Junes! Not so in the world of the Walking Dead.

#9 Posted by Fitzgerald (386 posts) -

It's too hard for me to say... Clementine seems more believable as a kid, but then again Nanako always says "Welcome back!" when you come home... TOUGH CALL.

#10 Posted by Icicle7x3 (1247 posts) -

Nanako x100000000

#11 Posted by Little_Socrates (5834 posts) -

Nanako is a major reason The Walking Dead is not one of my favorite games of the year.

#12 Posted by Hizang (9359 posts) -

You spend much more time with Nanako, plus Nanako is an innocent where as Clementine brings about some of the negative issues on herself.

#13 Posted by Hunter5024 (6447 posts) -

I think Clementine is a more believable character.

#14 Posted by Master_Funk (748 posts) -

Nanako easily.

#15 Posted by MisterSamMan (371 posts) -

Everyday is miserable in Georgia...so Nanako.

#16 Posted by EuanDewar (5155 posts) -


#17 Posted by Cold_Wolven (2386 posts) -

Nanako is just so gosh darn adorable who always brings a smile to my face when she sings the Junes song.

#18 Posted by FLStyle (5694 posts) -
Loading Video...
#19 Posted by ImmortalSaiyan (4748 posts) -

I would say Clementine is the better character who is far better acted. Put there is a charm to Nanako and her undying love of Junes. Still giving it to clem which is major praise to The Walking Dead for me to prefer anything about it over Persona 4.

#20 Posted by Abendlaender (3006 posts) -

Junes! I mean Nanako of course

#21 Posted by Ramone (3076 posts) -

Clementine, not only because she's endearing but also she can take a fool out when necessary.

#22 Posted by BabyChooChoo (5407 posts) -


Junes > some stupid goddamn hat

#23 Posted by Sweep (9752 posts) -

I'm cool if y'all prefer Nanako. Just means I don't have to share Clem with any of you.

#24 Posted by Gruff182 (999 posts) -

Who the fuck is Nanako?

#25 Posted by Mr_Skeleton (5195 posts) -

Clementine hands down, Nanako is annoying.

#26 Edited by Amafi (1151 posts) -

Clementine is far better written, acted, and less annoying.

#27 Posted by dr_mantas (2374 posts) -

Nanako, and I haven't played Persona 4. Loved the Walking Dead, but she's basically a walking talking plot device + emotional magnet there.

I guess the Endurance Run rubbed of on me.

#28 Posted by Robaota (174 posts) -

I can't pick. I just know that in my fanfic I'm writing they're best friends and nothing bad happens to either of them ever.

#29 Posted by TobbRobb (5216 posts) -


#30 Posted by Brodehouse (10653 posts) -

I like it when Nanako says welcome back really matter-of-factly.

Oooh, a lamp!

#31 Posted by GunslingerPanda (5030 posts) -

Clementine. Nanako was annoying.

#32 Posted by Sargus (764 posts) -

Clementine. She's a more believable character who I felt much more attached to.

#33 Posted by AuthenticM (4247 posts) -

Both are great, but my heart is with Nanako.

#34 Posted by kindnivore (2954 posts) -

No idea who Nanako is, so I guess I vote goes for Clementine.

#35 Posted by A_Cute_Squirtle (783 posts) -

You're asking this on a website where most of its members have already formed an attachment to Nanako via the Endurance Run.

Nanako, obviously.

#36 Posted by 2HeadedNinja (2007 posts) -

Clem, no doubt about it.

#37 Posted by TheDudeOfGaming (6115 posts) -

You guys are fucking nuts. Clementine obviously.

#38 Posted by NoobSauceG7 (1332 posts) -

Nanako. No contest.

#39 Posted by Nux (2558 posts) -

Nanako, no contest.

#40 Posted by zombie2011 (5271 posts) -

Clem is annoying always going on about her parents and shit. Nanako has no mom and Dojima is never there, but she doesn't give a fuck about any of that. As long as gets to buy a kotatsu from Junes once every couple years she's happy.

#41 Posted by Fredddi43 (413 posts) -

Clementine. Character of the year. I thought I would say that for Dust, but Clementine is a character I'll truly miss.

#42 Posted by Getz (3444 posts) -

You're gonna make me choose?! You're a monster.

#43 Posted by themangalist (1853 posts) -

@Little_Socrates said:

Nanako is a major reason The Walking Dead is not one of my favorite games of the year.

For me as well. We've all been there before as giantbombers.

#44 Posted by Sayishere (1852 posts) -

Oh man, i dunno. I like them both!

#45 Posted by Demoskinos (16437 posts) -

Clem because well I haven't played Persona 4.

#46 Posted by LackingSaint (2002 posts) -

Clementine for me, I don't think i've seen character development that well-done for any child character in a game.

#47 Posted by EpicSteve (6909 posts) -

Which one has had to use a gun? Clementine hardened.

#48 Posted by siln (94 posts) -

There is no wrong answer here, but I'll go to bat for Nanako. We've got veggies!!!

#49 Posted by Irvandus (3105 posts) -

Nanako, Clementine's character is iffy sometimes.

Plus (Spoiler for P4) When she is put in danger it is more effective because she has a relationship built with a player over the course of 70 hours as opposed to Clementine who is in danger from hour one so the jab is never quite as strong because you are used to Clementine always being in bad situations.

#50 Posted by LTSmash (708 posts) -

@Robaota said:

I can't pick. I just know that in my fanfic I'm writing they're best friends and nothing bad happens to either of them ever.

Nanako, Clemintine and The Mystery of the Haunted House