Haven't seen the UPF, obviously, but this seems like something super annoying. Having them look at a game they've already looked at. Especially when it's in the UPF format and you're basically paying to see them look at a game they already looked at for free.
Yeah, I think they should skip stuff that has already been featured in some form on the site. Maybe Rorie could do a quick glance at the steam page before putting stuff into the poll to see if it seems to be a joke entry or not. There were interesting poll options like Exodus from the Earth, Verdun, Paragon etc. in there, but the joke entries won every time.