I think the people defending Dany's turn are kind of missing the point of the detractors' real complaints about the turn of events in this episode. Nobody's denying that her turn to villainy wasn't foreshadowed or telegraphed seasons back (hell I pretty much called it at the beginning of the season when discussing the show with a friend). It's the execution that's completely lacking. She literally goes from slightly rattled to committing genocide in the span of 2 days. Even her father took years for his mental health to degrade to the point where he became the Mad King. Her seeing one of her dragons die and her advisor be decapitated isn't really convincing enough for me to buy her going full Hitler for something that had nothing to do with the people of King's Landing in the first place. Not to mention she suffered much greater personal tragedy in the past when she lost Drogo and her son, and still didn't really go completely ape shit.
To the people that say she has always been ruthless and burned anyone who got in her way, nearly all of those were either enemies that refused to yield or complete pieces of shit (such as the slave masters that crucified all those children). She's never committed full on genocide on a city just for the sake of it. In fact, seasons back, where she was presented with the burnt corpse of a child that one of her dragons casually murdered, she was so horrified, that she locked her dragons in a cave to prevent anything like that happening again. She was ruthless, but only when the situation called for it. Her just deciding to go psycho in the last second when pretty much the entire city had unanimously surrendered felt like very contrived set piece writing that was there simply to get the story from point A to point B. Dany going full on Griffith is fine on paper, but we need much more than half a season to effectively communicate that, let alone a single fucking episode.
Arya being shoved into the fray also felt very contrived as well. It felt like a dumb plot device the writers cooked up in the last second to give her enough motivation to kill Danerys. Cleganebowl was fine. Jaime going out with Cersei was fine. I really don't understand people's shock at that scene-it felt pretty consistent with what we've seen of Jaime's character throughout the show. Overall, this was simultaneously both the DUMBEST and the most entertaining episode of the season so far. The cinematography and visuals were gorgeous-much better than the battle of Winterfell. At times it felt like you were watching a moving painting and at least it didn't feel like a struggle to sit through the way ep 1, 2 and 4 felt.
Story/Writing: 4/10
Production Value/Spectacle: 9/10
Now that I got that off my chest, here are some memes:
Log in to comment