Kinnikuren

haha you guys are right, the deserted island with internet scenario doesn't make much sense.  
 
wow does have near-infinite replay value but i don't think i really have as much fun playing it as i do other games.  the grind would get to me after a while.  i'm gonna revise my choice to civ iv.

Or the one game you'd take with you to a deserted island.  Same diff.
 
Let's assume you have internet access, so multiplayer is a go.
 
I'm personally not sure myself, I want to say starcraft but i suck at it.

michaelangelo, he's a party dude

but sometimes the unnamed marine is the one that saves the day.  for me,  it'd depend on how awesome the suit/armor is. 

first year law school, crushing my soul

i was just using giantbomb to make lists and i stumbled on the quests.  then, four hours later, still going at it...